Best Short Term MYGA Annuities — Short-term multi-year guaranteed annuities (MYGAs) typically span 2 to 5 years. They offer locked-in interest rates, principal protection, and more predictable growth than variable investments. In this guide, we’ll help you compare yields, surrender periods, bonus features, and penalty-free withdrawal rules—so you can choose the MYGA that best complements your income plan without sacrificing flexibility and minimizing Market Value Adjustments.

What Makes a MYGA “Short Term”?

Short-term MYGAs usually refer to guarantee periods of 2, 3, or 5 years. Their value lies in delivering a known, fixed return over a defined, relatively brief horizon. They sit between ultra-short instruments (like CDs) and long-dated income annuities, offering a mix of yield and flexibility without locking in too far out. Because you know the rate ahead of time, MYGAs are especially helpful in laddering strategies that match income timing.

Key Variables to Compare

When shopping short-term MYGAs, compare:

• Effective rate vs. nominal: Bonus or rate-hold periods can inflate advertised rates temporarily.
• Surrender schedule: Charges for early withdrawals beyond free allowances.
• Penalty-free withdrawals: Some MYGAs permit up to 10% or more free access each year.
• Renewal options: At maturity, you’ll often have a window to renew or move money without penalty.
• Carrier strength & ratings: Guarantees depend on issuer solvency over the guarantee term, not on capital markets.

Yield vs. Liquidity Trade-Offs

As with bonds, longer guarantees tend to offer higher yields. A 5-year MYGA often beats a 2-year, but that extra juice comes at the expense of limited flexibility. If there’s a chance you’ll need funds in year 3, forcing a surrender can undermine expected returns. For clients planning multi-phase income or tax timing, I recommend staggered MYGA ladders or blending with fixed indexed annuities. For early retirement projects, you may also want to see how lifetime income features play into your broader plan in Annuity Strategies for Early Retirees.

Sample MYGA Ladder

Consider splitting $100,000 into a 2-year, 3-year, and 5-year MYGA. As the 2- and 3-year rungs mature, you can reinvest, ladder forward, or begin withdrawals. This approach balances yield and flexibility while minimizing the penalty risk of having all funds tied up. It’s especially valuable when market yields are volatile.

Tax Deferral & Growth Multipliers

Unlike CDs or Treasuries, MYGAs compound tax-deferred, which enhances yield over time. Even a modest return “lift” from deferral can compound meaningfully over the guarantee horizon. A higher-yield MYGA may outperform a public bond after tax in many bracket scenarios.

Risks and What to Watch Out For

Inflation risk, rate environment shifts, and credit risk are key. If inflation spikes, a fixed MYGA may lag real returns. If rates fall, you might be “locked in” at lower yield for a few years. And while MYGAs are conservative, they’re backed by the insurer’s general account—not FDIC. Always check provider ratings and align your plan term to your cash flow roadmap.

Choosing the Best MYGA for You

Begin with your time horizon: If you expect to use the funds within 3 years, favor a 2-year MYGA to minimize surrender risk. If 5 years feels secure, step up to a 5-year offer. Always confirm whether bonus rates or rate holds expire, how renewals behave, and whether free withdrawals are allowed. Need help mapping income timelines? Bench your MYGAs against your income goals and rollover plans.

Related Reading

• Annuity Rollover Options for Teachers
• Social Security Filing Checklist
• How Social Security Disability Impacts Retirement Benefits