Are annuities worth it? For many retirees and pre-retirees, the answer is yes — but the value of an annuity depends entirely on your goals, timeline, liquidity needs, and risk tolerance. Annuities are not one-size-fits-all products, and understanding where they fit in your retirement plan can help you avoid mistakes while maximizing benefits like guaranteed income, principal protection, and tax-deferred growth. At Diversified Insurance Brokers, we walk clients through the pros, the trade-offs, and the real numbers so you can make a confident, informed decision.

Before diving in, it helps to understand that fixed annuities offer principal protection and predictable interest, while fixed indexed annuities provide growth potential linked to market indexes — without market loss. On the income side, learning how lifetime income works is essential for comparing annuities to withdrawals from investments, pensions, and other retirement assets. Understanding these differences is the foundation for deciding whether an annuity is worth it for your financial situation.

Why Many People Consider Annuities “Worth It”

Annuities are often appealing because they solve specific retirement challenges that investment accounts alone cannot guarantee against. For example, a fixed annuity provides contractually guaranteed interest regardless of market conditions. A fixed indexed annuity protects against loss while offering attractive upside potential. Meanwhile, an income annuity or an income rider provides a guaranteed paycheck for life — no matter how long you live.

Longevity risk (outliving your savings) is one of the most significant concerns for retirees. Market volatility, inflation, and unexpected spending shocks can quickly erode a portfolio. For clients who want predictable income or a guaranteed minimum return, annuities can provide peace of mind. As you weigh your options, it’s helpful to compare annuities with other guaranteed products and ask: “What would it take for my investments to provide the same stability?”

Types of Annuities and What They’re Worth For

The value you receive from an annuity depends heavily on choosing the right type:

Fixed Annuities

Fixed annuities offer a guaranteed interest rate for a set period and are often compared to CDs. The difference lies in tax treatment and withdrawal options. They are often worth it for individuals who want strong, predictable yields with zero market exposure. For someone retiring soon, fixed annuities can act as a “safe bucket” within a larger retirement plan.

Fixed Indexed Annuities

Fixed indexed annuities (FIAs) credit interest based on market index performance, subject to caps, spreads, or participation rates — but with no downside risk. These annuities may be worth it for those who want market-linked upside while prioritizing principal protection. They also appeal to people who want income riders to support long-term retirement planning.

Income Annuities

Income annuities (SPIAs, DIAs, and FIAs with lifetime income riders) are specifically designed to provide monthly income for life. For individuals without a pension or for couples concerned about outliving assets, these contracts can be extremely valuable. Understanding how guaranteed payout structures work helps frame how annuities compare with other income sources.

When Annuities Are Worth It — and When They Aren’t

While annuities deliver meaningful benefits, they are not right for everyone. They are most effective when aligned with specific goals:

• You want principal protection. Fixed and indexed annuities guarantee you won’t lose money due to market downturns.
• You want predictable lifetime income. Income riders and SPIAs create lifetime paychecks that markets cannot replicate with certainty.
• You want tax-deferred growth. Similar to retirement accounts, annuities grow without annual taxation.
• You want to shift longevity risk to an insurer. Annuities can guarantee income even if you live to 100+.
• You want stability in retirement planning. Annuities function as a commitment device, anchoring part of your plan in certainty.

However, annuities may be less suitable if liquidity is your top priority, or if your timeline does not justify surrender periods. Individuals with short-term goals or unpredictable cash-flow needs should be cautious. It’s also important to understand how RMDs interact with annuities if part of your retirement assets sit inside an IRA.

Are Indexed Annuities Worth It?

For many people, yes — especially those seeking a balanced approach between growth and safety. Indexed annuities can outperform traditional safe products over the long run, particularly as interest rates shift. Their worth increases when the goal is long-term growth without market losses, or when pairing them with an income rider that enhances payout guarantees.

Indexed annuities are also valuable for diversification. They can complement equities, bonds, and alternative investments by reducing volatility in the overall retirement plan. Compared to taxable investment accounts, tax-deferred growth can improve long-term accumulation outcomes.

Are Fixed Annuities Worth It?

Fixed annuities are often considered one of the most straightforward and worthwhile options for conservative investors. They typically outperform CDs on a tax-equivalent basis and provide flexible renewal or transfer options. When evaluating whether a fixed annuity is worth it, comparing today’s rates with other safe instruments is crucial — especially with rising interest rate environments improving yields.

You can compare the strongest fixed annuity offerings using our current fixed annuity rates page, and you can explore upfront incentive options through bonus annuity opportunities, which may offer higher initial value depending on your strategy.

The Cost of an Annuity vs. Its Worth

To decide whether an annuity is worth it, you need to understand how annuity pricing works. Unlike investments that charge ongoing fees, most fixed and indexed annuities have no direct annual cost. Instead, insurance companies earn a margin on internal yield spreads. Income riders typically come with transparent, stated fees. Understanding how annuity costs work helps contextualize what you receive for the guarantees provided.

The key question is always: “What would it cost me to reproduce these guarantees on my own?” For almost all retirees, the answer is significantly more than the cost of the annuity’s internal pricing.

Calculator: See Whether an Annuity Is Worth It for You

Note: Calculator supports premiums up to $2,000,000. Larger contributions scale proportionally.

Compare Today’s Top Annuities

Are Annuities Worth It for Income Planning?

For individuals seeking a dependable retirement paycheck, annuities can be extremely valuable. Lifetime income riders often provide far stronger guarantees than market-based withdrawal strategies. The worth of these products increases further when paired with Social Security strategies or when coordinating required distributions. They are especially helpful for individuals who do not have a pension or who want to protect a spouse with joint lifetime benefits.

Income annuities also simplify planning. Instead of wondering how long your savings will last, you know exactly how much income you will receive and when. These stable payments reduce stress, improve budgeting, and allow for a more confident retirement lifestyle.

Are Annuities Worth It for Inheritance Planning?

Depending on the type, annuities can also provide meaningful value for beneficiaries. Some annuities offer enhanced death benefits, predictable transfers, or structured payout options. While annuities are not always the primary legacy tool, they can complement life insurance or trusts. For individuals concerned about minimizing risk or ensuring stability for heirs, annuities may be worth it as part of a broader estate strategy.

Get a Personalized Annuity Recommendation

Key Questions to Ask When Deciding Whether an Annuity Is Worth It

Before purchasing any annuity, you should evaluate:

• Your liquidity needs over the next 5–10 years
• Your overall retirement income plan
• Whether you need growth, income, or stability
• How an annuity interacts with RMDs, taxes, and other accounts
• Your comfort level with market volatility
• Your desire for guaranteed lifetime income

For some people, annuities will be an essential piece of their retirement puzzle. For others, they may be a complementary tool — or unnecessary. The value lies not in the product itself but in how well it aligns with your goals.

Final Thoughts — Are Annuities Worth It?

Annuities are worth it when they solve a meaningful financial problem: protecting principal, guaranteeing income, stabilizing returns, or improving retirement confidence. They are not speculative investments, nor are they designed for short-term liquidity. Their purpose is long-term security. If that aligns with your personal goals, annuities can be among the most valuable tools available.

At Diversified Insurance Brokers, we evaluate your age, goals, timeline, tax picture, liquidity needs, and risk tolerance to determine whether an annuity adds meaningful value — and if so, which type will deliver the most benefits.

Related Pages

• Group Long-Term Care
• Best Fixed Indexed Annuities for Income
• Life Insurance for Electricians
• What Should I Do With My Pension After I Retire?
• Burial Insurance for Seniors Over 50
• Premium Financing Pros and Cons