Turning 65 is a milestone—and for most people, it’s also the start of a brand-new healthcare system with unfamiliar rules, deadlines, and penalties. Medicare is not “automatic” for everyone, and enrolling at the wrong time (or choosing the wrong combination of coverage) can create expensive gaps you don’t notice until you’re sitting in a doctor’s office or at the pharmacy counter. At Diversified Insurance Brokers, our licensed Medicare advisors make the process simple. We help you enroll on time, avoid late penalties, and align your choices—Original Medicare, Medigap, Medicare Advantage, and Part D—with your doctors, your prescriptions, your travel habits, and your budget.

The goal is not just to “get Medicare.” The goal is to build a Medicare setup that works in the real world. That means confirming your effective dates, verifying whether you can delay Part B without penalty, checking networks and drug formularies if you’re considering Medicare Advantage, and making sure you understand how Medigap works during your open enrollment window. It also means planning for the common “gotchas” that trip people up: COBRA misunderstandings, retiree plans that don’t protect you from Part B penalties, HSA contribution rules, and Part D late enrollment penalties that can follow you for life.

Diversified Insurance Brokers is a family-owned agency serving clients nationwide since 1980. We help people compare Medicare options the right way—based on your medical providers, your prescriptions, and your personal preferences—not based on a one-size-fits-all recommendation. If you’d like to dig in now, you can use the plan comparison tool below and then connect with our Medicare advisor for a personalized recommendation.

Before we get into the step-by-step process, it helps to understand the “shape” of Medicare. Medicare is made up of separate parts that work together. Part A generally covers inpatient hospital care. Part B generally covers outpatient care—doctor visits, tests, imaging, outpatient surgery, durable medical equipment, and preventive services. Part D is prescription drug coverage. Then you choose how you want to package the rest: either you stay on Original Medicare (Part A + Part B) and add a Medigap policy and Part D drug plan, or you choose a Medicare Advantage plan (Part C) that bundles Part A and Part B (and usually Part D) into one plan with networks and copays. That choice—Original Medicare + Medigap + Part D versus Medicare Advantage—drives most of your long-term experience.

If you’re brand new to Medicare, it can feel like a lot of moving parts. The good news is that the timeline is predictable once you understand the enrollment windows. Most people enroll during the Initial Enrollment Period (IEP), which is a seven-month window around your 65th birthday. You can enroll three months before your birth month, during your birth month, and for three months after. The timing matters because it affects when your coverage starts. In general, enrolling earlier tends to reduce the chance of delays or gaps—especially if you’re also coordinating employer coverage or a retirement date.

Your IEP is the simplest window because it’s built specifically for people turning 65. If you enroll one to three months before your 65th birth month, your coverage can start the month you turn 65. If you enroll in your birth month, your coverage often starts the following month. If you enroll one to three months after your birth month, your start date can be delayed further. That doesn’t mean you “can’t” enroll later in your IEP—it just means we want to plan carefully to avoid any unintended gap in coverage, especially if you’re stopping employer coverage when you retire.

Now for one of the biggest decision points: what if you’re still working at 65? Many people can delay Part B without penalty—but only if the coverage you have is considered creditable and the employer size rules support delaying. As a general rule, if you have employer coverage through a company with 20 or more employees, that group plan is typically primary and Medicare is secondary. In that scenario, you may be able to delay Part B (and often Part D) without penalty while you continue working. The key is documenting everything, keeping proof of creditable coverage, and understanding your Special Enrollment Period (SEP) for when you retire or lose coverage.

If the employer has fewer than 20 employees, Medicare often becomes primary at 65, and the employer plan becomes secondary. This is where people get burned. If you stay on a small employer plan and don’t enroll in Part B at 65, you can end up with denied claims or unexpected out-of-pocket costs because Medicare should have been primary. This is exactly why a quick “employer size + creditable coverage” review is one of the first things our Medicare advisors do. If you want a deeper explanation of how employer size affects your timing, review our guide on employer coverage rules here: creditable coverage and employer size.

COBRA and retiree coverage create another common trap. Many people assume COBRA works like employer coverage, but for Medicare timing, COBRA usually does not protect you from Part B late enrollment penalties if you delay Part B after your active employment ends. Retiree coverage is similar—sometimes it’s helpful as a supplement, but it often doesn’t allow you to delay Part B without consequences. The safe approach is to confirm whether your plan is considered creditable for Part B and Part D, and to map your retirement date to your Medicare effective dates. A short planning call can prevent years of higher premiums and avoidable confusion.

If you contribute to an HSA, Medicare enrollment requires extra planning. Once Part A starts, you generally cannot keep contributing to an HSA. The complication is that Part A can be retroactive up to six months in certain situations, which means you may need to stop HSA contributions up to six months before enrolling to avoid tax issues. This doesn’t mean you can’t use your HSA funds—you can still use the account for qualified expenses—but contributions are the issue. If you’re working past 65 and actively contributing to an HSA, we’ll coordinate the timing so you don’t accidentally create a tax headache.

Once you understand timing, the next step is choosing your Medicare structure. Many retirees prefer Original Medicare + Medigap + Part D because Medigap can reduce out-of-pocket uncertainty and typically avoids networks. That structure is especially attractive for people who travel, want broad provider access, or see specialists in different health systems. Medicare Advantage can be a strong fit as well, particularly for people who want lower monthly premiums, prefer an all-in-one plan, and are comfortable staying in-network. Advantage plans often include extra benefits like dental, vision, hearing, fitness, and OTC allowances, but the trade-off is that you will typically have networks, copays, prior authorizations, and plan changes year to year.

Medigap has its own critical window: the six-month Medigap Open Enrollment period that begins when your Part B becomes effective (and you’re 65 or older). During this window, you can generally buy a Medigap plan without medical underwriting. After that window, depending on your state and situation, you may be subject to underwriting, meaning your health history can affect acceptance and pricing. This is why we emphasize planning Part B effective dates carefully—your Medigap “best window” is tied to Part B.

Prescription coverage (Part D) is another area where timing matters. If you don’t enroll in Part D when you’re supposed to, and you don’t have creditable drug coverage, you can face a late enrollment penalty that may last as long as you have Part D coverage. Even if you rarely take medications today, Part D protects you against future risk and helps avoid penalties. When we help clients enroll, we run prescriptions through plan tools to verify costs, preferred pharmacies, tier placement, and whether medications require prior authorization. If you’re on expensive medications, the difference between plans can be dramatic—even within the same county.

Because Medicare is local, one of the most important things we do is “ground the plan choice in your zip code.” Medicare Advantage plan availability and pricing vary by county. Part D pricing and formularies vary by plan. Medigap premiums vary by carrier, pricing method, and household discounts, and they also vary by state. That’s why a quick online search or a friend’s plan recommendation may not translate well to your own situation. The right approach is to compare the options available where you live and verify they fit your doctors and prescriptions.

For clients who want a clear enrollment roadmap, we typically walk through the same structured process. First, we confirm whether you’re already receiving Social Security benefits. If you’re drawing Social Security before 65, you may be automatically enrolled in Part A and Part B, and you’ll receive your Medicare card. If you are not receiving Social Security, you’ll typically enroll through Social Security when you’re ready. Second, we confirm whether you’re working and whether you have group coverage, and we determine if delaying Part B makes sense. Third, we map out your desired Medicare structure: Original Medicare + Medigap + Part D, or Medicare Advantage. Fourth, we verify doctors, hospitals, and prescriptions. Finally, we help you complete enrollment and selection steps so your coverage starts when you want it to start.

One reason this matters is that Medicare penalties are not small “oops” fees. A Part B late enrollment penalty can be permanent and can increase your premium for life if you delay without eligible creditable coverage. Part D penalties can also follow you long-term. Even worse than penalties are coverage gaps—when you assume you’re covered, but coordination of benefits makes your claim deny or shifts costs to you unexpectedly. That’s why we recommend planning your enrollment several months before you turn 65 if possible.

Let’s talk through the most common real-life scenarios. The first scenario is the straightforward one: you’re retiring at or around 65. In that case, most people enroll in Part A and Part B during their IEP (usually a month or two before turning 65 to avoid delays), then choose either a Medigap plan and Part D plan or a Medicare Advantage plan effective the same month. We then double-check effective dates and help confirm your doctors and prescriptions are aligned with the plan selection.

The second scenario is: you’re still working and covered by a large employer plan. In that case, you may choose to enroll in Part A at 65 (since most people can get Part A premium-free) while delaying Part B. Some people choose to delay Part A too because of HSA contributions, depending on how their benefits are structured. When you retire, you’ll use your Special Enrollment Period to enroll in Part B without penalty, and then you’ll choose Medigap + Part D or Medicare Advantage. This is where proof matters: you want documentation of creditable coverage and active employment so the transition is smooth.

The third scenario is: you’re working but the employer is small. In that case, you generally want to enroll in Part A and Part B at 65 so Medicare is primary. This helps avoid denied claims and unexpected bills. The employer plan may still provide coverage as secondary, but Medicare becomes your base. Many people in this scenario also choose a Medigap plan to control out-of-pocket exposure, especially if they anticipate medical usage.

The fourth scenario is: you’re on COBRA, retiree coverage, or an individual plan (including ACA coverage) as you approach 65. In many cases, Medicare will become primary at 65 and you’ll want to enroll on time. COBRA is not the same as active employer coverage for Medicare rules, and delaying Medicare because you have COBRA often leads to penalties and coverage confusion. If you’re in this situation, it’s worth reviewing early so the transition is clean and cost-effective.

Now let’s address the big “choice” question: should you choose Medigap or Medicare Advantage? There is no universal answer, but there is a clear way to evaluate it. If you prioritize provider flexibility, travel convenience, predictable cost exposure, and fewer plan changes, Original Medicare + Medigap + Part D is often a strong fit. If you prioritize lower monthly premiums, bundled benefits, and you’re comfortable with networks and annual plan changes, Medicare Advantage may be attractive. The best approach is to model both structures using your doctor list and prescriptions, and to consider your health needs now and your risk tolerance for future costs.

Medigap decisions often come down to two things: how you feel about ongoing premiums versus out-of-pocket risk, and how important broad provider access is to you. Medigap can reduce or eliminate many of the out-of-pocket expenses associated with Original Medicare, which is why many people describe it as the “sleep well at night” choice. The trade-off is that Medigap policies have monthly premiums, and you still need a Part D plan for prescriptions. Medicare Advantage often has lower premiums but higher variable costs when you use care, along with networks and plan controls like prior authorization.

Part D deserves special attention because it is one of the areas where “details matter.” Two Part D plans can have similar premiums but very different costs for your medications. Formularies change. Pharmacy networks matter. Mail order rules matter. And if you take specialty medications, the difference in annual cost can be substantial. Our process is to run your medications through available plans and identify the best combination of premium and out-of-pocket cost, while also making sure your preferred pharmacy works well with the plan.

Some clients also ask about IRMAA—income-related monthly adjustment amounts for Part B and Part D. While we won’t calculate tax outcomes inside a Medicare selection call, we will help you understand how Medicare premiums may be higher based on income and how that impacts budgeting. If you’re retiring and your income is changing, it’s helpful to plan ahead so there are no surprises.

If you’re already thinking about retirement planning beyond Medicare, you may also want to explore how insurance and retirement income strategies fit together. Many clients coordinate Medicare planning with broader retirement protection planning, including annuities for guaranteed income. If that’s a priority, you can review our annuity education center here: annuities. The reason this can matter is that healthcare costs often become one of the largest line items in retirement, and stable income can make budgeting and long-term planning far easier.

To make this concrete, here’s an example we see frequently. Linda turned 65 and was still working for a large employer. She wanted to avoid unnecessary premiums while she was covered through her employer plan, but she didn’t want penalties later. We confirmed her employer coverage was creditable, documented it properly, and delayed Part B. When she retired, we used her Special Enrollment Period to enroll her in Part B and then helped her choose a Medigap and Part D combination that matched her physicians and prescriptions. The result was no gaps, no penalties, and a clean transition.

Another example: a client on COBRA assumed COBRA would allow them to delay Part B until COBRA ended. We reviewed the situation early enough to correct course. By enrolling in Part B at the appropriate time and aligning supplemental coverage correctly, we prevented future penalties and avoided a coverage gap that could have created denied claims. These “one decision” moments are exactly why a professional review is valuable.

If you want help, the next step is simple: use the comparison tool above, then connect with our Medicare advisor. We’ll confirm your enrollment window, discuss whether you can delay Part B, and compare the plan structures available in your area. We’ll also help you avoid the common pitfalls that cause penalties and frustration.

Finally, as you make decisions, it helps to remember that Medicare is not just about picking a plan for this year. It is about building a structure you can live with for years. The “best” plan is the one that works with your actual providers, your prescriptions, your budget, and your preferences for networks and predictability. Medicare is manageable when you have a clear process—and that’s exactly what our team provides.

Related Pages

Creditable Coverage and Employer Size | Annuities | Current Annuity Rates | How to Evaluate an Insurance Company | Contact Us