Life insurance for cigar smokers is one of the most misunderstood parts of underwriting—because cigar use does not always mean you’ll be charged smoker rates. In fact, many people who smoke cigars occasionally can qualify for non-smoker life insurance rates with the right carrier, the right disclosures, and the right underwriting strategy.

At Diversified Insurance Brokers, we specialize in getting cigar smokers classified correctly the first time. We’re an independent, family-owned, fiduciary insurance agency licensed in all 50 states, and we work with a large network of top-rated carriers. That matters because carriers do not treat cigar use the same way—some are extremely strict, while others are surprisingly favorable when the profile is clean.

Here’s the key point: as long as someone is not using cigarettes (and is not mixing in other tobacco products), there are often legitimate pathways to non-smoker pricing—even if they enjoy cigars. The underwriting outcome comes down to frequency, nicotine testing, carrier rules, and whether the application is positioned correctly.

Can Cigar Smokers Really Get Non-Smoker Life Insurance Rates?

Yes—many cigar users can qualify for non-smoker rates, and sometimes even preferred non-smoker rates depending on the carrier and the full file. This is why “cigar smoker” isn’t automatically the same thing as “tobacco rating.” Underwriters look at cigar use differently than daily cigarette smoking because cigars are often used less frequently and many cigar users don’t inhale.

However, the biggest deal-breaker is usually cigarette use. If someone uses cigarettes—even occasionally—most carriers will treat them as a tobacco user and pricing will jump significantly. That’s why we focus on two goals from the start: (1) disclose cigar use correctly, and (2) confirm there is no cigarette use or mixed tobacco use that would force smoker rates.

If you’ve ever been quoted smoker rates simply because you mentioned cigars, that doesn’t always mean the pricing was accurate—it often means the agent used a carrier with strict rules or didn’t understand how to shop underwriting correctly.

How Life Insurance Underwriting Classifies Cigar Use

Most life insurance companies classify cigar smokers based on a handful of underwriting variables. The reason outcomes vary so much is that each carrier weights these variables differently—some are rigid, and some are flexible.

Here’s what insurers usually care about:

• Frequency: Is it rare (celebratory), occasional, or weekly?
• Cigarette use: If you also use cigarettes, you’re almost always going to be treated as tobacco.
• Nicotine test results: Blood and urine may show nicotine/cotinine depending on timing and frequency.
• Other tobacco products: Chewing tobacco, vaping, pipes, nicotine pouches, etc.
• Overall health profile: Blood pressure, cholesterol, build, medical history, medications, and family history.

If you’re trying to understand how pricing works when underwriting gets stricter, it can help to read these two guides:

• Life Insurance Table Ratings Explained
• Life Insurance with Pre-Existing Conditions

The Most Important Rule: No Cigarettes

To be very direct: as long as someone is not using cigarettes, we can often pursue carrier options that allow cigar use with non-smoker pricing. That’s true even if they smoke cigars during special events, while traveling, on the golf course, or during holidays.

What gets people overcharged is when an application gets lumped into a “tobacco” category due to vague wording, incomplete detail, or the wrong carrier submission. We prevent that by documenting cigar use clearly in the way underwriters want to see it, and then targeting carriers that treat cigar profiles correctly.

And if someone is unsure whether their past habits might be interpreted as cigarette use, we help them clarify the timeline and present it in a way that avoids confusion and delays.

What Happens If Nicotine Shows Up on the Exam?

Nicotine testing is a major variable—because it can override what you disclose on the application. Some carriers will give non-smoker rates to cigar users only if the exam shows negative nicotine/cotinine. Other carriers may still classify you as a cigar user (not a cigarette smoker) even if the lab comes back positive, depending on their guidelines and how the activity is disclosed.

This is exactly why carrier selection matters. If you’re going to take an exam, timing and transparency matter, but the bigger advantage is working with an agency that knows how to navigate the underwriting differences.

For applicants who do want the cleanest possible underwriting path, we can talk through how carriers approach lab testing and what is most realistic—without guessing.

Why Cigar Smokers Get Overcharged (and How We Prevent It)

Most people don’t get overcharged because they smoke cigars. They get overcharged because the application was submitted in a way that forced the carrier into a worst-case assumption.

Here are the most common reasons we see cigar users quoted incorrectly:

• The agent submitted the case to a carrier that automatically assigns tobacco rates for any cigar use.
• The application did not clearly state frequency, or it sounded more frequent than it actually is.
• The applicant had any cigarette use, even “rare,” which triggered smoker classification.
• A nicotine test came back positive and the carrier had zero flexibility.
• The case was not shopped—so the applicant only saw one company’s opinion.

Our process is different because we compare carriers first and aim for the best possible classification based on the facts. We also make sure the underwriting summary is clean, consistent, and doesn’t accidentally create red flags.

What Types of Policies Work Best for Cigar Smokers?

Cigar smokers can qualify for the same life insurance structures as non-tobacco users. The difference isn’t the policy type—it’s the underwriting class and how the carrier prices the risk.

Most clients start by looking at term life insurance because it’s typically the most affordable way to get a large death benefit. Term coverage is often ideal during peak responsibility years—income replacement, mortgage protection, and family protection.

Some cigar users prefer permanent life insurance if they want lifelong coverage or long-term planning benefits. Another common strategy is to start with term and keep flexibility for the future using convertible term life insurance options. That way, you’re not locked into one plan forever.

If you’re also comparing workplace coverage versus your own policy, this guide can help:

• Group vs Individual Life Insurance

How Much Can You Save With Non-Smoker Rates?

When a cigar smoker qualifies for non-smoker rates, the savings can be significant. Smoker pricing is often dramatically higher, and over the life of a policy that difference can add up to thousands—or even tens of thousands—depending on age, coverage amount, and term length.

The goal isn’t to “game” underwriting. The goal is to be classified accurately. If your lifestyle truly fits a non-smoker-friendly guideline, you shouldn’t pay cigarette-level premiums.

Estimate Your Rates (Calculator)

Why Work With Diversified Insurance Brokers?

When cigar use shows up on an application, the difference between a great offer and an overpriced offer is rarely the cigar itself—it’s the underwriting execution.

Diversified Insurance Brokers is a family-owned, fiduciary insurance agency licensed in all 50 states. Since 1980, we’ve helped clients nationwide get life insurance approved correctly, even in cases involving complex underwriting, lifestyle factors, and high-risk scenarios. We don’t assume every carrier will treat you the same—because they won’t.

• Independent, fiduciary advisors who work for you
• Nationwide support (all 50 states)
• Carrier shopping to find non-smoker-friendly underwriting for cigar users
• Clear expectations before you apply

Related Pages