Is American Equity a Good Insurance Company?
Jason Stolz CLTC, CRPC
Is American Equity a good insurance company? It’s a fair question—and an important one—because the entire purpose of an annuity is to create long-term certainty. You’re not buying a “short-term” product. You’re choosing a carrier that may hold your retirement dollars for years, pay you income for decades, and remain financially stable through multiple economic cycles.
American Equity Investment Life Insurance Company is one of the best-known names in fixed annuities and fixed indexed annuities (FIAs) in the United States. The company has built a strong niche in retirement-focused insurance solutions—particularly for people who want principal protection, tax-deferred growth, and the option to create predictable, contractually defined income later.
At Diversified Insurance Brokers, we work with retirees and pre-retirees nationwide who want clear answers about where their money should go. Sometimes American Equity is a great fit. Other times, a different company may offer better liquidity, a stronger income rider structure, or more favorable crediting terms on the day we run comparisons. Our job is to put the numbers next to each other so your decision is based on facts—not marketing.
In this guide, we’ll break American Equity down in the same practical way we do when we help a client make a decision: what the company does well, where it tends to fit best, how its annuities are designed, what to watch for in the fine print, and how to compare it objectively against other carriers before you move a dollar.
Request Your American Equity Annuity Quote
Get guaranteed income numbers and rate comparisons from top-rated carriers, including American Equity.
We’ll compare pricing, contract terms, and guaranteed income side-by-side so you can choose with confidence.
Quick Answer: Is American Equity “Good”?
If you want the short version before we go deeper: American Equity is widely regarded as a strong annuity carrier, especially for fixed indexed annuities and retirement income planning. They’re not trying to be everything to everyone. Their identity is very clear: annuities that protect principal and support retirement outcomes.
That said, “good insurance company” does not always mean “best annuity for you.” The best contract depends on:
Your time horizon (do you need income soon or later?), your liquidity needs (how much access do you want each year?), your risk tolerance (do you want fixed interest, indexed interest, or a mix?), and how the rider math works at your age and income start date.
American Equity can absolutely be a good fit in many cases. But the way you get the best outcome is not by picking a company first. It’s by defining your objective and then choosing the contract that matches it.
What American Equity Is Known For
American Equity focuses primarily on fixed annuities and fixed indexed annuities (FIAs). These products are designed for people who want protection from market losses while still aiming for interest crediting and retirement income options.
Unlike variable products, FIAs are not built around the idea that you should “ride the market.” They’re built around the idea that retirement planning should feel more like engineering than speculation. That’s one of the reasons American Equity has become a familiar name among people nearing retirement who are looking for stable solutions.
Many people first discover American Equity because they want one of the following outcomes:
Guaranteed lifetime income (creating a paycheck you can’t outlive), principal protection (no market loss exposure), tax-deferred growth (especially in non-qualified funds), or simplified retirement planning (replacing complicated portfolios with contract-based guarantees).
At Diversified Insurance Brokers, we often compare American Equity against other annuity specialists to see where they’re most competitive on the day we quote. That’s because annuity value is highly time-sensitive. Rates and crediting terms can change. Riders get updated. New versions come out. What’s “best” today can shift later.
American Equity Financial Strength (What It Means for Your Retirement)
Financial strength is one of the first filters we use when helping clients evaluate annuity carriers. The reason is simple: annuities are promises. A contract is only as strong as the company behind it.
American Equity has historically carried strong ratings in the “excellent to strong” range from major rating agencies. These ratings reflect an insurer’s ability to meet long-term obligations, maintain reserves, manage risk, and operate with sufficient capital. In practical terms, when you choose a carrier with solid financial strength, you’re choosing a higher level of confidence that the company will be there when you need it—not just now, but 10, 20, or 30 years from now.
That said, financial strength is only one piece. We also evaluate the contract design, surrender schedule, liquidity rules, rider expenses, and how the policy behaves under real-world retirement scenarios.
A strong company can still offer a contract that isn’t competitive for your age, timeline, or goal. That’s why the best evaluation process is not “ratings only.” It’s “ratings plus contract math.”
Where American Equity Fits Best (Real-Life Planning Context)
One of the biggest mistakes we see is people trying to use the same annuity logic for every retirement scenario. But retirees don’t all have the same goals. Some want growth. Some want income. Some want protection with access. Some want a hybrid strategy where part of the money is guaranteed and part stays liquid.
American Equity often fits best when the objective is one of the following:
1) Creating guaranteed lifetime income without giving up principal protection. Many of American Equity’s FIAs can be structured around income riders designed to turn a lump sum into predictable withdrawals.
2) Building a “retirement income floor” that reduces pressure on investments. If you have market-based assets, adding guaranteed income can help you avoid selling investments at the wrong time.
3) Repositioning conservative assets like CDs, savings, or low-yield bonds into a contract that provides better long-term structure, while still keeping a portion of annual access.
4) Long-term planning for income later (not immediately). Some contracts become more attractive when the income start date is pushed out, because the income base calculations can have more time to develop.
If your goal is near-term liquidity, short-term flexibility, or maximum “cash-out” access with minimal restrictions, another carrier or a different strategy may be better. This is why we always start with your timeline and your withdrawal needs before we make any product recommendations.
Fixed Annuity vs. Fixed Indexed Annuity (Why It Matters)
To evaluate American Equity correctly, you have to understand the difference between a traditional fixed annuity and a fixed indexed annuity. People use the term “annuity” as if it’s one thing. It isn’t.
A fixed annuity typically credits a declared interest rate for a set time period. It’s simple, predictable, and easy to understand. You deposit money, the contract grows at a stated rate, and you can withdraw or convert to income later.
A fixed indexed annuity (FIA) uses index-based crediting strategies. That means the contract can credit interest based on the performance of an index (like the S&P 500), but you are not invested in the market. You are not buying shares. You are using a formula governed by contract rules such as caps, participation rates, or spreads.
FIAs exist because many retirees want a middle ground: more upside potential than a pure fixed rate, but without market downside risk. American Equity plays heavily in this space.
If you want a deeper understanding of how this works mechanically, this is one of our most helpful educational pages: How Do Annuities Earn Interest?
How to Evaluate American Equity the Right Way (Not Just the Logo)
“Is American Equity good?” is really shorthand for a bigger question: Is an American Equity annuity good for my exact situation? That requires a real comparison process.
Here’s how we evaluate the fit with clients:
Step one: Identify your purpose. Are you buying for income, accumulation, protection, legacy, or a combination?
Step two: Identify the time frame. When do you want to access the money? When do you want income to start?
Step three: Identify your liquidity needs. Do you need access every year? Do you want a large emergency reserve? Do you already have a separate cash bucket?
Step four: Compare the contract mechanics. This is where the real value is. Two annuities can sound similar but behave very differently when you run actual numbers.
At Diversified Insurance Brokers, we compare across top carriers because we are not trying to “sell a brand.” We’re trying to match you with the best contract design for your objective.
Ensure you are receiving the absolute top rates
Current Fixed Annuity Rates
Compare today’s best fixed annuity rates from top carriers.
Current Bonus Annuity Rates
See which annuities offer the highest upfront bonus today.
Request an Annuity Quote
Submit our annuity request form to get personalized rate options.
Lifetime Income Calculator
Use our calculator to see how much guaranteed income your annuity can provide.
Popular American Equity Annuity Products (What They’re Designed to Do)
American Equity has multiple annuity lines and product series. Instead of listing product names as a marketing sheet, it’s more useful to understand the roles these products are designed to play inside a retirement plan. That’s the only way to compare them intelligently.
Some American Equity contracts are built more for accumulation—meaning the focus is on index-linked crediting and long-term value growth under protected rules. Others are built more for income—meaning the focus is on rider design, income base calculations, payout factors, and predictable distribution planning.
A common misconception is that you need one annuity that does everything. In reality, many retirees benefit from a “two-bucket” annuity approach: one contract designed for stable accumulation and liquidity, and another contract designed specifically for income. That’s one reason comparisons matter.
If you’re looking at product series like income-focused designs, bonus-oriented designs, or traditional MYGA-style options, the most important question is not “What’s the name?” It’s “What does it do?”
In many cases, American Equity annuities can include features such as:
Index strategies with different crediting methods, income riders that build an income base over time, withdrawal provisions that allow annual access, and death benefit rules that determine how value passes to beneficiaries.
If you want to understand one of the most overlooked parts of annuity ownership, review this: Annuity Free Withdrawal Rules. Liquidity is where many annuities are misunderstood, and it’s one of the first things we review with clients.
What “Guaranteed Income” Really Means (And What It Doesn’t)
Most people come to American Equity looking for “guaranteed income.” But that phrase gets misused in the marketplace, so it’s important to define it clearly.
Guaranteed lifetime income generally means the annuity can provide withdrawals for as long as you live (and sometimes as long as you or your spouse lives). That guarantee is contractual. It is not based on market performance. It’s not dependent on an advisor’s strategy. It’s written into the policy.
However, guaranteed income does not always mean:
Maximum possible income at every age, complete liquidity without limits, or no trade-offs. Every annuity has trade-offs. Income riders have costs. Surrender schedules exist. Crediting strategies have rules.
The way you evaluate guaranteed income is by comparing the actual numbers based on your age and start date. A “great annuity” for someone starting income at 70 can be a poor fit for someone who wants income at 62. This is why we always model it.
If you want to understand the framework many carriers use for retirement income riders, here’s a helpful guide: What Is a GLWB Rider?
Liquidity, Access, and Surrender Charges (The “Real-World” Test)
One of the most important parts of annuity ownership is what happens when life changes. Retirement rarely goes exactly as planned. People move. Health changes. Family needs arise. Homes need repairs. Adult children need help. That’s why liquidity matters.
Most American Equity annuities—like most fixed and indexed annuities—include a surrender period. During that period, if you take more than the contract allows in penalty-free withdrawals, you may face a surrender charge. This is not unique to American Equity. It is a standard annuity structure.
The key is understanding the surrender structure and designing the plan accordingly. If you want an annuity for income planning and you already have cash reserves elsewhere, surrender schedules are often manageable. But if you want maximum flexibility, we may design around shorter terms, stronger free withdrawal provisions, or a different approach entirely.
This is also why we often recommend people keep a separate emergency fund outside the annuity, rather than forcing the annuity to become the emergency fund. An annuity is primarily a retirement contract—not a checking account.
How American Equity Compares to Other Annuity Carriers
American Equity competes in a space where multiple strong carriers exist. Some carriers are known for higher payout factors at certain ages. Others are known for richer accumulation crediting terms. Some are known for liquidity advantages. Others may excel in income rider design.
That’s why we rarely recommend choosing based on brand alone. Instead, we benchmark a small group of carriers that are competitive for your objective, and we compare:
Guaranteed income at your chosen start date, rider fees, free withdrawal provisions, surrender schedules, index crediting options, and how beneficiaries are treated.
In other words: we compare what matters—not what sounds good.
For example, if income is your priority, we often look at the broader retirement-income annuity marketplace and build the recommendation from there. A helpful overview is here: What Is the Best Retirement Income Annuity?
What to Watch For Before Buying Any American Equity Annuity
Even when American Equity is a strong fit, we still want clients to understand what they’re buying clearly. A “good annuity” becomes a frustrating annuity when someone buys it for the wrong reason or misunderstands how it works.
Before you commit, make sure you can answer these questions:
When do I want income to start? If you want income soon, the contract needs to be evaluated differently than if you’re planning 7–10 years out.
How much liquidity do I need? If you want large withdrawals early, we need to structure around that or choose a different design.
Am I prioritizing growth or income? The best product for accumulation is not always the best product for income.
Do I understand the rider cost? Income riders typically charge a fee. You need to know what you are paying and what you get for it.
Do I understand crediting rules? If the annuity is indexed, you should understand caps, participation rates, spreads, and the strategy options.
How does it treat beneficiaries? Retirement planning includes legacy planning. We always review beneficiary rules.
If your plan involves leaving something behind, this is a helpful resource: Annuity Beneficiary & Death Benefits
When American Equity Is a Strong Choice (And When It Might Not Be)
American Equity is often a strong choice when you value principal protection, contract-based guarantees, and a retirement-focused annuity company. Many of their products are designed with income planning in mind, which is a major reason people consider them.
However, American Equity might not be the best fit if you need maximum early liquidity, if you want a very short-term strategy, or if another carrier is simply offering a better income payout or better crediting terms for the exact same objective at the time you’re shopping.
The goal isn’t to “find a good company.” The goal is to find the best contract for your retirement.
Bottom Line: Should You Consider American Equity?
Yes—American Equity is a legitimate and respected annuity carrier with a strong track record in fixed and fixed indexed annuities, and it can be an excellent fit for retirees who want guaranteed income planning and principal protection.
But the smart move is not to buy American Equity because you’ve heard the name. The smart move is to compare American Equity alongside other top carriers and choose the contract that produces the best outcome for your specific age, premium, timeline, and income goals.
If you want help, we’ll do the comparison for you and show you the results in plain English so you know exactly what you’re buying and why it fits.
Want personalized figures? We’ll compare American Equity against today’s top annuity carriers and deliver a clear, written breakdown.
Related Pages
Talk With an Advisor Today
Choose how you’d like to connect—call or message us, then book a time that works for you.
Schedule here:
calendly.com/jason-dibcompanies/diversified-quotes
Licensed in all 50 states • Fiduciary, family-owned since 1980
FAQs: Is American Equity a Good Insurance Company?
Is American Equity a good insurance company for annuities?
American Equity is widely considered a strong annuity-focused insurer, particularly in fixed and fixed indexed annuities. The best choice depends on your goals (growth vs. income), your timeline, your state, and how the specific contract compares to other carriers available the same day.
What does American Equity specialize in?
American Equity is primarily known for annuities—especially fixed indexed annuities (FIAs) and other retirement-income-oriented designs. That focus can be helpful if your objective is principal protection and contract-based income planning.
Is American Equity financially strong?
American Equity is generally viewed as financially solid for long-term guarantees, but “financial strength” should always be considered alongside the specific product terms you’re buying—because a strong company can still offer a contract that isn’t the best value for your scenario.
How do American Equity fixed indexed annuities work?
Fixed indexed annuities credit interest based on index-linked strategies governed by contract rules such as caps, participation rates, or spreads. You are not directly invested in the market, and principal is typically protected from market loss, subject to surrender schedules and contract provisions.
Can American Equity provide guaranteed lifetime income?
Many American Equity annuities can be structured for guaranteed lifetime income, commonly through an optional income rider. When comparing options, focus on rider cost, income base growth rules, payout factors, and the income start date you want.
Are American Equity annuity rates and payouts competitive?
They can be, but competitiveness changes over time and varies by product and state. The most reliable approach is to compare multiple carriers side-by-side using the same premium, age, and income start date.
What are the most important contract details to review?
Pay close attention to the surrender schedule, penalty-free withdrawal provisions, any rider charges, how interest is credited, how the income base is calculated (if applicable), and how beneficiaries are treated.
What happens to an American Equity annuity if I die?
Most annuities include beneficiary provisions, but the exact death benefit terms vary by contract and rider elections. Confirm the beneficiary rules before purchase—especially if lifetime income has started or if certain riders change how remaining value is handled.
Is American Equity better than Allianz or other major carriers?
It depends on the specific products being compared, your state, and your goals. In many cases, a carrier may be strong in one category (income rider design, liquidity, bonuses, or accumulation) but not the best overall for your exact timeline.
How should I compare American Equity annuities to other options?
Use the same inputs across carriers (age, premium, state, single vs. joint life, income start date) and compare guaranteed income results, rider costs, surrender schedules, penalty-free withdrawals, and beneficiary treatment—then choose the contract that best fits your objectives.
About the Author:
Jason Stolz, CLTC, CRPC and Chief Underwriter at Diversified Insurance Brokers (NPN 20471358), is a senior insurance and retirement professional with more than two decades of real-world experience helping individuals, families, and business owners protect their income, assets, and long-term financial stability. As a long-time partner of the nationally licensed independent agency Diversified Insurance Brokers, Jason provides trusted guidance across multiple specialties—including fixed and indexed annuities, long-term care planning, personal and business disability insurance, life insurance solutions, Group Health, and short-term health coverage. Diversified Insurance Brokers maintains active contracts with over 100 highly rated insurance carriers, ensuring clients have access to a broad and competitive marketplace.
His practical, education-first approach has earned recognition in publications such as VoyageATL, highlighting his commitment to financial clarity and client-focused planning. Drawing on deep product knowledge and years of hands-on field experience, Jason helps clients evaluate carriers, compare strategies, and build retirement and protection plans that are both secure and cost-efficient. Visitors who want to explore current annuity rates and compare options across multiple insurers can also use this annuity quote and comparison tool.
