How do Annuities Earn Interest
Jason Stolz CLTC, CRPC
When we are asked by our customers How do Annuities Earn Interest, the answer is in a few different ways depending on the contract type. At a high level, a fixed annuity credits a declared rate, a fixed indexed annuity credits interest based on an external market index formula with principal protection, and a RILA (registered index-linked annuity) uses crediting formulas with defined downside exposure and upside potential. Understanding how rates are declared, how caps, spreads, and participation rates work, and how interest compounds helps you choose the right contract for your goals.
For foundational refreshers, see our fixed annuity overview and our fixed indexed annuity basics. When you’re ready to compare methods, our index crediting methods guide explains point-to-point, monthly average, monthly sum, and volatility-controlled index strategies in plain English.
See Current Crediting Options & Rates
Compare fixed, indexed, and multi-year guarantees before you choose a strategy.
Four Ways Annuities Credit Interest
Here’s how the primary crediting approaches differ and where each tends to fit:
| Type | How Interest Is Determined | Downside Risk | Typical Use Case |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed (MYGA) | Declared rate (e.g., 3–6%) guaranteed for a multi-year term. | None to principal if held; market risk is offloaded to insurer. | Safe accumulation, CD alternative. See current fixed annuity rates. |
| Fixed Indexed | Index-linked formula with caps, spreads, or participation; never credits negative interest. | Principal protected from market loss; credits can be 0% in bad periods. | Growth with downside protection. Start with fixed vs fixed indexed comparison. |
| RILA | Index formulas with buffers or floors; more upside than FIA, some controlled downside. | Limited downside via buffer/floor; not principal-protected like FIAs. | Targeted risk/return. Learn the basics in what is a RILA. |
| Immediate/Income | Converts premium into guaranteed payments; internal interest is implicit in payout rate. | No market risk; payments guaranteed per option chosen. | Creating a paycheck now. See guaranteed income from annuities. |
How Indexed Crediting Really Works
Fixed indexed annuities credit interest based on an external index (e.g., S&P 500® price return) without exposing your principal to market loss. Instead of receiving the index’s full return, the contract applies a cap (maximum), spread (subtracted percentage), or participation rate (percentage of the index change). These terms are set by the insurer and can vary by strategy and renewal period.
- Annual point-to-point with cap: If the index rises 12% and the cap is 6%, you’d be credited 6% for that term. If the index falls, your credit is 0%, not negative.
- Annual point-to-point with spread: Index gain minus spread (e.g., 10% – 2% = 8%).
- Participation rate: A share of the gain (e.g., 50% of a 10% increase = 5% credit).
- Volatility-controlled indices: Custom benchmarks target steadier volatility so carriers can offer higher caps/parts.
For illustrations of each approach and when to use them, see our index crediting methods guide.
Declared Rates, Renewal Terms, and Compounding
In a fixed or MYGA annuity, the insurer declares a guaranteed rate for a specific term (e.g., 3, 5, or 7 years). Interest generally compounds annually and adds to your account value. At renewal, you can take a penalty-free withdrawal (usually up to 10%), renew, or exchange the contract.
In a fixed indexed annuity, credited interest is locked in each term and becomes part of your protected principal. Over multiple terms, this produces a ratchet effect: new credits add on top of prior gains while market declines cannot reduce past credits.
Key Levers That Affect Your Crediting
- Strategy mix: You can usually split premium among several strategies. Diversifying across caps and participation rates can smooth results.
- Carrier renewal rates: Carriers reset caps/parts/spreads at each anniversary within contractual minimums. Strong general account management often supports more competitive renewals.
- Term length: Longer surrender schedules can support higher initial crediting; shorter terms add flexibility. Learn the tradeoffs in annuity surrender charges explained and free withdrawal rules overview.
- Bonus structures: Some contracts add an upfront premium bonus or crediting bonus which can impact overall value. Compare structures, not just a headline bonus.
- Riders: Optional income riders credit a separate roll-up on an income benefit base (not cash value). Understand the difference using our roll-up vs payout rate explainer.
Tax Treatment of Credited Interest
Inside an annuity, credited interest grows tax-deferred; you don’t receive a 1099-INT each year. Taxes generally apply when you withdraw gains, and rules differ for qualified vs. non-qualified money. For a primer, review our guide to how annuities are taxed.
Estimate Your Lifetime Income
Model how different crediting approaches translate into future income—then compare today’s top carriers.
Practical Steps to Choose a Crediting Strategy
- Define your objective: Are you seeking steady accumulation (MYGA), asymmetric growth with downside protection (FIA), or targeted risk with a buffer (RILA)? Start with our side-by-side comparison guide.
- Align your time horizon: If you’ll need liquidity soon, shorter terms and higher free-withdrawal allowances matter more. Review free withdrawal rules overview.
- Mix strategies wisely: Split across cap and participation strategies (and possibly a fixed bucket) to balance potential and stability.
- Focus on renewal quality: Today’s attractive caps matter—tomorrow’s renewals matter more over time.
- Compare real-world quotes: See the live landscape on our current fixed annuity rates page, then request carrier-specific illustrations.
Check Today’s Annuity Rates
Compare MYGA, fixed indexed, and immediate income options side-by-side.
Talk With an Advisor Today
Choose how you’d like to connect—call or message us, then book a time that works for you.
Schedule here:
calendly.com/jason-dibcompanies/diversified-quotes
Licensed in all 50 states • Fiduciary, family-owned since 1980
Frequently Asked Questions
Do fixed annuities compound at a guaranteed rate?
Yes. Fixed and MYGA annuities credit a declared rate that compounds over the guarantee term. At renewal, you can withdraw, renew, or exchange.
Can fixed indexed annuities lose money in a down market?
No market-loss to principal when held per contract terms. In negative index years, the credit is typically 0%, not negative.
What’s the difference between a cap, spread, and participation rate?
A cap is a maximum credited return, a spread is a percentage subtracted from gains, and a participation rate is the portion of the index gain you receive.
How do rider roll-ups relate to interest earnings?
Income riders often credit a separate roll-up rate on an income base used to calculate future payouts. It’s different from cash value growth.
Where can I compare today’s crediting options?
Start with our annuity rates and options page, then request personalized quotes based on age, state, and goals.
