How Are Annuities Taxed?
How Are Annuities Taxed?
Jason Stolz CLTC, CRPC, DIA, CAA
How Are Annuities Taxed — The Complete Guide to Qualified vs. Non-Qualified, Withdrawals, Annuitization, and Inherited Contracts
How annuities are taxed depends on three questions answered at the time of distribution: whether the money funding the annuity was pre-tax or after-tax, how the distribution is taken, and who is receiving it. Get those three questions right and annuity taxation is consistent, predictable, and in many cases more favorable than most retirement account owners realize. At Diversified Insurance Brokers, Jason Stolz, CLTC, CRPC, DIA, CAA works with pre-retirees and retirees designing tax-aware retirement income plans — evaluating how annuity distributions interact with Social Security taxability, Medicare premium surcharges, Required Minimum Distributions, and the complete taxable income picture before any commitment is made. How tax deferral creates compounding advantage over multi-year accumulation periods is the foundational reason most non-qualified annuities are purchased — the earnings inside the contract accumulate without annual tax drag, which produces a larger balance available for income or legacy than a comparably performing taxable account would have generated over the same period.
Qualified Annuities — When Pre-Tax Dollars Fund the Contract
A qualified annuity is funded with pre-tax retirement account dollars — through an IRA rollover, a 401k trustee-to-trustee transfer, or a direct contribution to a qualified annuity contract. Because the original contributions were never taxed, every dollar that comes out of a qualified annuity is taxable as ordinary income in the year received, regardless of whether the distribution is taken as a withdrawal, a systematic payment, or a fully annuitized income stream. There is no exclusion ratio, no basis recovery, and no capital gains treatment — the entire distribution is ordinary income because no after-tax basis exists in the contract. This is identical to the tax treatment of any other traditional IRA or 401k distribution and should not be surprising to anyone who has managed qualified retirement accounts. What to do with an IRA after retirement — including the specific decision of whether IRA funds should remain in market-exposed positions, roll into a principal-protected annuity, or be annuitized for guaranteed income — is the account-level decision immediately preceding the tax analysis for qualified annuity buyers. The comparison between annuities and 401k plans as accumulation and distribution vehicles establishes the structural differences that inform whether a qualified rollover into an annuity is the appropriate repositioning for a specific retirement situation.
Required Minimum Distributions from qualified annuities follow the same IRS rules as all traditional IRAs — distributions must begin at the applicable RMD age and are calculated using the prior year-end account value divided by the IRS life expectancy factor. Most annuity contracts are designed to accommodate annual RMD withdrawals within the free withdrawal provision, but confirming this before purchase is essential — an annuity that does not accommodate the RMD without triggering surrender charges creates an unintended financial burden during the years when distributions are mandatory rather than voluntary. The RMD interaction also affects tax planning: each mandatory qualified annuity distribution adds to the year’s ordinary income total, which can affect Social Security benefit taxability, IRMAA Medicare premium surcharges, and overall bracket management. Coordinating the qualified annuity’s distribution schedule with the complete income picture — Social Security claiming timing, other IRA balances, and any pension — is the planning discipline that prevents RMDs from generating more taxable income than necessary in any given year.
Ensure you are receiving the absolute top rates
Current Fixed Annuity Rates
Compare today’s best fixed annuity rates from top carriers.
Current Bonus Annuity Rates
See which annuities offer the highest upfront bonus today.
Request an Annuity Quote
Submit our annuity request form to get personalized rate options.
Lifetime Income Calculator
Use our calculator to see how much guaranteed income your annuity can provide.
Non-Qualified Annuities — Tax Treatment by Distribution Method
| Distribution Method | Tax Mechanics | Planning Implication |
|---|---|---|
| Partial withdrawal (LIFO) | Last-in, first-out treatment applies — earnings are deemed distributed before basis; withdrawals are fully taxable as ordinary income until all accumulated gain has been distributed; basis recovery begins only after all taxable earnings have been distributed | Buyers planning early-accumulation-phase withdrawals from a highly appreciated contract should anticipate fully taxable distributions until the gain is exhausted; timing withdrawals to manage bracket exposure — taking distributions in lower-income years rather than peak-income years — can reduce the net tax cost of accessing the contract’s earnings |
| Full surrender | The entire gain over basis is recognized as ordinary income in the year of surrender; the basis is returned tax-free; if the contract is surrendered at a loss (contract value below original premium), a deduction may be available — this is uncommon for fixed or fixed indexed annuities with principal protection but can occur if rider fees have eroded the account value below the original premium | Full surrender in a high-income year can produce a large ordinary income recognition event; if surrender is planned, executing it in a year of lower income — the year of retirement, for example — reduces the marginal rate applied to the recognized gain; a 1035 exchange into a new annuity avoids full surrender taxation while repositioning the contract |
| Annuitized income stream (exclusion ratio) | Each periodic payment includes a tax-free return of basis portion and a taxable ordinary income portion; the exclusion ratio is calculated by dividing the investment in the contract by the expected return over the annuity’s payment term; the non-taxable portion of each payment continues until all basis has been recovered, after which payments become fully taxable | Annuitized payments from a non-qualified contract are more tax-efficient per payment dollar than LIFO withdrawals in the early distribution years because basis is spread across all payments rather than deferred to last; for buyers who plan to activate income and hold for life, annuitization can reduce the effective annual tax burden on the income stream compared to systematic withdrawal from an appreciated contract |
| GLWB income rider withdrawals | Income rider withdrawals from non-qualified annuities are not formal annuitization — they are contractual withdrawals from the account value, which follow LIFO treatment; earnings come out first as ordinary income until the gain is exhausted; once basis is fully depleted by prior withdrawals or rider fees, payments may become entirely tax-free if the account value has reached zero and the contract is paying solely from the carrier’s contractual income obligation | For buyers using income riders on non-qualified contracts, the tax character of each payment shifts over time as the gain-to-basis ratio changes; early payments are fully taxable; later payments transition toward tax-free as basis is recovered; understanding this transition is important for long-term income planning and for coordinating the annuity’s after-tax cash flow with other income sources |
The table establishes the key planning principle: for non-qualified annuity owners, how distributions are structured — withdrawal versus annuitization — affects the annual tax burden on the income stream in ways that can meaningfully change the after-tax monthly income received. Fixed annuities compared to CDs in terms of tax treatment illustrates why tax-deferred accumulation inside an annuity produces a different after-tax compounding result than a CD whose interest is taxable annually — the comparison directly demonstrates why buyers prioritize tax deferral in the accumulation phase even when the pre-tax growth rates are equivalent.
The 10% Early Withdrawal Penalty — When It Applies and the Exceptions
Annuity distributions taken before age 59½ are subject to a 10% federal early withdrawal penalty on the taxable portion of the distribution, in addition to ordinary income tax. This penalty applies to both qualified and non-qualified annuities on the earnings portion of early distributions. For qualified annuities, the penalty mirrors the early distribution penalty applicable to traditional IRAs. For non-qualified annuities, the penalty applies to the earnings distributed under LIFO treatment before age 59½. The penalty does not apply to distributions that qualify for a statutory exception — including distributions made as part of a series of substantially equal periodic payments under Section 72(t), distributions made due to death or disability, or distributions made from certain employer plan annuities following separation from service.
The practical planning implication is straightforward: annuity owners who purchase a contract before age 59½ should structure the contract term and withdrawal provisions to avoid accessing taxable earnings before the penalty age if at all possible. Annual free withdrawal provisions — typically up to 10% of the account value per year in most FIA contracts — are available without surrender charges but do not exempt the withdrawal from the 10% early distribution penalty if the owner is under 59½. Annuity surrender charges are a separate contractual penalty distinct from the IRS early distribution penalty — both can apply simultaneously on an early full surrender, creating a compounding cost that must be understood before any pre-59½ surrender decision is made. Annuity strategies for early retirees cover how buyers who retire before 59½ can structure annuity income — including the 72(t) substantially equal periodic payment approach — to access contract earnings without triggering the early distribution penalty.
The 1035 Exchange — Moving Between Annuities Without a Tax Event
Section 1035 of the Internal Revenue Code allows an annuity owner to exchange one annuity contract for another without recognizing the accumulated gain as taxable income at the time of the transfer. The basis from the original contract carries forward into the new contract, preserving the tax-deferred status of the gain and resetting the contract terms — including the income rider design, surrender schedule, and index crediting structure — without a taxable distribution event. The 1035 exchange is the repositioning tool that allows annuity owners who hold contracts with outdated income rider terms, uncompetitive crediting parameters, or surrender periods that have elapsed to move into more favorable current-market products without the tax cost of a full surrender. How 1035 exchanges work in annuity planning — the mechanics of the direct carrier-to-carrier transfer, the cost basis carryforward, and the analysis required before executing an exchange — is the reference guide for any annuity owner considering whether repositioning makes financial sense for their specific contract situation.
The 1035 exchange is also the mechanism that links annuity taxation to long-term care planning for non-qualified contract holders. Under the Pension Protection Act, non-qualified annuity assets can be exchanged via 1035 into a hybrid annuity-LTC contract, and distributions from the new contract used to pay for qualified long-term care expenses are received income-tax-free — a significant planning advantage for buyers who want to address both income and care cost protection within a single tax-advantaged structure. Non-qualified long-term care annuities cover this specific 1035 exchange-funded LTC structure in full — the product design, the tax treatment of LTC distributions, and why the Pension Protection Act exchange is one of the most underused tax planning tools available to holders of appreciated non-qualified annuity contracts.
Annuity Taxation at Death — How Beneficiaries Are Taxed
When an annuity owner dies, the tax treatment of the death benefit depends on whether the contract was qualified or non-qualified, who the named beneficiary is, and how the beneficiary elects to receive the death benefit. For qualified annuities, the death benefit is taxable as ordinary income to the beneficiary under the same rules that apply to inherited IRA distributions — the SECURE Act’s 10-year rule applies to most non-spouse beneficiaries, requiring full distribution of the inherited contract within 10 years of the owner’s death. For non-qualified annuities, the gain over basis at the time of death is taxable as ordinary income to the beneficiary — the step-up in basis available for inherited appreciated stocks does not apply to annuity contracts, which means the accumulated tax-deferred gain that was never taxed during the owner’s lifetime must ultimately be recognized by the beneficiary. How annuity death benefits work for beneficiaries — the distribution options available to surviving spouses versus non-spouse beneficiaries, the 5-year rule versus the income period certain option, and how the beneficiary’s distribution election affects the rate at which the gain is recognized — is the estate and legacy planning dimension of annuity taxation that owners frequently overlook when structuring their contracts. Annuity beneficiary designation mechanics — and specifically why the beneficiary designation on an annuity contract is a legal document that governs the death benefit distribution independently of the owner’s will — establish the administrative responsibility that every annuity owner must manage to ensure the contract’s death benefit reaches the intended recipients under the most favorable available tax terms. The death trap — the specific estate planning scenario where annuity gains pile up inside a contract and create a large ordinary income event for beneficiaries — illustrates why proactive beneficiary planning and distribution strategy during the owner’s lifetime produces better after-tax outcomes for the estate than deferring the taxation decision entirely to beneficiaries.
Roth Conversions Alongside Annuity Income — Managing the Tax Rate Transition
One of the most powerful applications of non-qualified annuity income in a retirement tax plan is as a complement to a Roth conversion strategy. A retiree who holds both a non-qualified annuity and a traditional IRA faces a sequential tax planning opportunity: using the annuity income (partially tax-free through the exclusion ratio or fully tax-free after basis recovery) to fund living expenses while converting traditional IRA balances to Roth at the current marginal rate — permanently reducing the future RMD obligation and creating a pool of tax-free income that diversifies the retirement tax picture. Roth conversions in coordination with a fixed indexed annuity addresses this specific strategy — how to use the annuity income’s tax characteristics to create Roth conversion capacity in the years before Social Security and RMDs fully establish the household’s taxable income floor. The complete Roth conversion framework covers when conversions are most valuable, how to calculate the conversion amount that fills available bracket space without pushing into the next rate tier, and how the conversion timeline interacts with Medicare premium planning and Social Security taxation. Maximizing Social Security benefits through optimal claiming strategy — and specifically how the claiming age decision affects the Social Security taxability calculation in future years — is a planning decision that directly interacts with both the annuity income structure and the Roth conversion opportunity during the pre-Social Security gap years. Whether working past 65 affects Social Security benefits addresses the earnings test, the bracket implications of earned income alongside annuity income, and how the IRMAA calculation applies when multiple income sources are layered together — context that matters for retirees managing annuity distributions alongside continued part-time earnings. Guaranteed income at age 65 contextualizes the annuity tax planning decision within the broader retirement income transition — the year of retirement is typically the optimal entry point for both the annuity structure and the Roth conversion window, when income is at its lowest between career earnings and full retirement income activation. What annuity guarantees mean at the contractual level — how the carrier’s obligation is backed by reserves and state guarantee associations — establishes the security context for placing long-term tax planning reliance on the annuity income stream. Downside protection strategies in bear markets frames the annuity’s principal protection function alongside its tax deferral function — both are planning advantages of the FIA structure that support the tax planning strategy built around guaranteed income.
Get a Tax-Aware Annuity Quote
We compare carriers and structure illustrations that show how withdrawals, income activation, and beneficiary design affect the after-tax picture for your specific qualified and non-qualified assets.
Talk With an Advisor Today
Choose how you’d like to connect—call or message us, then book a time that works for you.
Schedule here:
calendly.com/jason-dibcompanies/diversified-quotes
Licensed in all 50 states • Fiduciary, family-owned since 1980
FAQs: How Are Annuities Taxed?
Are annuity earnings taxed as capital gains or ordinary income?
Annuity earnings — whether from fixed interest, index-linked credits, or investment subaccount returns — are taxed as ordinary income when distributed, not as capital gains. This is one of the most important tax distinctions between annuities and taxable investment accounts. In a taxable brokerage account, long-term capital gains from appreciated securities held more than one year qualify for the preferential capital gains tax rate. Annuity distributions do not receive this treatment — the earnings are ordinary income regardless of how long the contract has been held and regardless of whether the underlying crediting mechanism tracked an equity index. This means that in high-income years, annuity distributions from appreciated non-qualified contracts are taxed at the same marginal rate as wages or IRA distributions.
The counterbalancing advantage is tax deferral during the accumulation phase — annuity earnings accumulate without annual taxation, which allows a larger balance to compound over time than would be available in a taxable account where gains are recognized and taxed each year. For buyers who hold the annuity for a long accumulation period and then distribute income over many years at a lower retirement marginal rate than their peak working rate, the tax deferral advantage over the full period can more than offset the loss of preferential capital gains treatment. Buyers who prioritize capital gains treatment over tax deferral and principal protection are generally better served by taxable investment accounts than annuities for the growth portion of their retirement assets.
What is the exclusion ratio and how does it reduce taxes on annuity income?
The exclusion ratio applies specifically to annuitized income payments from non-qualified contracts — it is the IRS mechanism that determines what portion of each periodic payment is a tax-free return of the owner’s original after-tax investment and what portion is taxable gain. The ratio is calculated by dividing the investment in the contract — the total after-tax premiums paid — by the expected return over the contract’s payment term. The resulting percentage represents the fraction of each payment that is excluded from taxable income until the entire basis has been recovered.
For example: if a buyer deposits $120,000 into a non-qualified annuity and annuitizes it into a $9,600 annual payment over 20 years, the total expected return is $192,000. The exclusion ratio is $120,000 divided by $192,000, or 62.5%. Each annual payment of $9,600 would include $6,000 that is excluded from income and $3,600 that is taxable as ordinary income, at least until the full $120,000 basis is recovered. After the basis is fully recovered, the remaining payments become fully taxable. For buyers whose primary goal is maximizing after-tax monthly income from a non-qualified annuity, annuitization’s exclusion ratio treatment produces a more favorable tax outcome per payment dollar in the early years of income than systematic withdrawals under LIFO treatment, which recognize earnings first before any basis recovery begins.
If I do a 1035 exchange, do I owe taxes on the gain in my existing annuity?
No — a properly executed 1035 exchange transfers the accumulated value of one annuity contract directly to another annuity contract without triggering a taxable distribution event. The gain that has accumulated inside the original contract is not recognized as ordinary income at the time of the exchange. Instead, the cost basis from the original contract carries forward into the new contract, and the deferred gain remains inside the new contract’s tax-deferred structure until actual distributions are made. The 1035 exchange must be executed as a direct carrier-to-carrier transfer — if the owner receives the funds personally at any point in the process, the IRS may treat the distribution as a taxable event regardless of the owner’s intent to reinvest.
The 1035 exchange is the tool that allows annuity owners to modernize their contracts — moving from an older product with outdated income rider terms, lower caps, or an expired surrender period into a current-market product with more competitive terms — without paying taxes on the accumulated gain that would otherwise make surrender undesirable. For owners holding highly appreciated non-qualified annuities where a full surrender would create a large ordinary income recognition event, the 1035 exchange is often the only financially rational path to repositioning the contract. The analysis before executing an exchange must confirm that the new product’s terms — income rider design, crediting parameters, surrender period, and any bonus credits — produce a better outcome over the remaining holding period than continuing to hold the existing contract, since the exchange restarts the surrender period in the new contract.
How does annuity income affect my Medicare premiums?
Annuity distributions — whether from a qualified IRA-funded annuity or from the taxable earnings portion of a non-qualified annuity under LIFO — are included in Modified Adjusted Gross Income for purposes of the IRMAA calculation, which determines Medicare Part B and Part D premium surcharges. IRMAA uses a two-year look-back: the premium surcharge applied in the current year is based on MAGI from two years prior. A retiree who begins taking significant annuity distributions — whether at income activation or through a full surrender — will see that income reflected in Medicare premiums two years later if the distributions push MAGI above the applicable IRMAA thresholds.
The IRMAA interaction does not make annuity income a poor planning choice — it means the distribution amount and timing should be planned with the Medicare premium impact modeled alongside the income benefit. Strategies that manage IRMAA exposure include structuring non-qualified annuity income to take advantage of the exclusion ratio, timing large taxable events such as 1035 exchange proceeds or full surrenders to avoid the highest IRMAA tiers, coordinating Roth conversions with annuity income to replace future taxable RMDs with tax-free Roth withdrawals, and using income start dates that align favorable lower-income years with the two-year look-back window. The IRMAA thresholds are adjusted periodically, so planning with specific tier numbers should be confirmed with current IRS and CMS publications at the time the income decision is being made.
Are annuity death benefits taxable to my beneficiaries?
Yes — the gain inside an annuity contract is taxable to beneficiaries when they receive the death benefit, and annuity contracts do not receive the step-up in basis that inherited stocks and real estate receive under current tax law. For qualified annuities, the full death benefit is taxable as ordinary income to the beneficiary because no after-tax basis exists in the contract — the entire accumulated value was pre-tax. For non-qualified annuities, the gain over the owner’s cost basis is taxable as ordinary income; the basis itself is returned tax-free. A surviving spouse who inherits a non-qualified annuity can typically continue the contract as their own, maintaining the tax-deferred status and deferring gain recognition. Non-spouse beneficiaries generally must take distributions from inherited annuities within a defined period — the five-year rule or a period-certain income option — during which the gain is recognized and taxed as the distributions are received.
The practical planning implication is that highly appreciated non-qualified annuity contracts can create significant income tax events for non-spouse beneficiaries who receive the full gain in a compressed time period. For owners whose primary legacy goal is leaving after-tax wealth to beneficiaries, the annuity’s death benefit taxation — ordinary income, no step-up — is less favorable than an equivalent amount left in appreciated securities with step-up in basis. For owners whose primary goals are income and principal protection during their lifetime, the annuity remains the appropriate instrument and the beneficiary tax event is managed through beneficiary designation planning, payout election guidance to beneficiaries, and in some cases 1035 exchanges into products with more favorable death benefit provisions during the owner’s lifetime.
Should I use qualified or non-qualified money to fund an annuity?
The decision depends on which planning objective the annuity is serving and what the tax environment looks like across both the accumulation and distribution phases. Using qualified money — IRA or 401k rollover — inside an annuity creates a fully taxable income stream that satisfies RMD requirements and coordinates with the complete qualified account distribution picture. This is appropriate when the primary objective is guaranteed income from pre-tax retirement savings, RMD management, or repositioning out of market-exposed qualified investments into a principal-protected structure. The annuity adds guaranteed income design and principal protection to the qualified account — the tax treatment is identical to any other IRA distribution and creates no additional tax complexity.
Using non-qualified after-tax money inside an annuity creates the tax deferral and exclusion ratio advantages that make annuities distinctively beneficial compared to taxable investments — the growth is deferred and a portion of each annuitized payment is tax-free basis recovery. This is most advantageous when the buyer has after-tax savings earning taxable annual interest or dividends and wants to convert those assets into a tax-deferred structure without contributing to a Roth IRA or triggering a taxable event. For buyers who have both qualified and non-qualified assets, a common planning approach is to reserve the annuity structure for non-qualified funds — capturing the distinctive tax deferral and exclusion ratio benefits that do not apply to the qualified account — while using qualified funds in non-annuity instruments that provide market exposure or liquidity appropriate for the qualified account portion of the retirement plan. This is a general framework rather than a universal rule; the optimal allocation depends on the specific amounts, income needs, tax bracket profile, and estate planning objectives of the individual household.
About the Author:
Jason Stolz, CLTC, CRPC, DIA, CAA and Chief Underwriter at Diversified Insurance Brokers (NPN 20471358), is a senior insurance and retirement professional with more than 25 years of real-world experience helping individuals, families, and business owners protect their income, assets, and long-term financial stability. As a long-time partner of the nationally licensed independent agency Diversified Insurance Brokers, Jason provides trusted guidance across multiple specialties—including fixed and indexed annuities, long-term care planning, personal and business disability insurance, life insurance solutions, Group Health, Travel Medical and Evacuation Insurance, and short-term health coverage. Diversified Insurance Brokers maintains active contracts with over 100 highly rated insurance carriers, ensuring clients have access to a broad and competitive marketplace.
His practical, education-first approach has earned recognition in publications such as VoyageATL, and contributions from his agency featured in Kiplinger and GoBankingRates— highlighting his commitment to financial clarity and client-focused planning. Drawing on deep product knowledge and years of hands-on field experience, Jason helps clients evaluate carriers, compare strategies, and build retirement and protection plans that are both secure and cost-efficient. Visitors who want to explore current annuity rates and compare options across multiple insurers can also use this annuity quote and comparison tool.
Explore More Annuity Options: Browse our complete guide to Annuity Strategies & Retirement Income — covering tax strategies, retirement income planning, lifetime income & annuity comparisons from 100+ carriers.
Last Reviewed: June 10, 2026 |
Reviewed by: Jason Stolz, CLTC, CRPC, DIA, CAA
Chief Underwriter, Diversified Insurance Brokers, Inc. | NPN: 20471358 | Licensed in all 50 states
Editorial Standards: Diversified Insurance Brokers maintains rigorous editorial standards to ensure accuracy, clarity, and independence in all content. Learn more about our editorial standards and commitment to transparency.
