Is GBU a Good Insurance Company?
Is GBU a Good Insurance Company?
Jason Stolz CLTC, CRPC, DIA, CAA
GBU Financial Life has been protecting the financial futures of American families since 1892 — over 130 years of continuous operation through the Great Depression, World War II, multiple recessions, the 2008 financial crisis, and everything in between. Founded in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania by German immigrants who needed affordable, trustworthy financial protection, GBU grew from a community mutual aid society into one of the most financially solid fraternal benefit organizations in the country. Today it holds an AM Best A- (Excellent) rating, $4.7 billion in assets, a $314 million surplus, and a financial promise that is simple and verifiable: for every $100 of obligations it owes its members, GBU holds $107 in assets. That cushion matters when you are choosing where to put retirement money. As a fraternal benefit society organized under IRS section 501(c)(8), GBU is legally structured as a not-for-profit member organization. When you buy a GBU annuity or life insurance product, you become a member — an owner — of the organization. There are no shareholders extracting profits, no administrative fees on annuities, and no conflict between maximizing policyholder returns and maximizing shareholder dividends. GBU’s financial gains stay within the membership. The product lineup covers what most retirement savers actually need: multi-year guaranteed annuities across an unusually wide range of terms, a single premium immediate annuity for income that starts now, the Asset Guard fixed indexed annuity for growth with principal protection, the Future Flex flexible premium deferred annuity for buyers building savings over time, and a Defined Benefit annuity for buyers seeking guaranteed income structured like a pension. Membership also brings access to scholarships, charitable giving programs, and Operation Reach Out — the program that ships care packages to military personnel overseas. At Diversified Insurance Brokers, Jason Stolz, CLTC, CRPC, DIA, CAA, evaluates GBU for clients who want an A-rated carrier with genuine community roots, strong financials, no fees, and a product lineup that is competitive enough to belong on any serious retirement savings comparison.
See Real-Term Rates Side by Side
Life Insurance Quoter
Ensure you are receiving the absolute top rates
Current Fixed Annuity Rates
Compare today’s best fixed annuity rates from top carriers.
Current Bonus Annuity Rates
See which annuities offer the highest upfront bonus today.
Request an Annuity Quote
Submit our annuity request form to get personalized rate options.
Lifetime Income Calculator
Use our calculator to see how much guaranteed income your annuity can provide.
What GBU Life Offers Retirement Savers
| What You Get | How It Works | Why It Matters for Your Retirement |
|---|---|---|
| A- Financial Strength | AM Best A- (Excellent); $4.7B assets; $314M surplus; $107 in assets for every $100 in obligations; 130+ years of continuous operation | A- is the minimum rating most financial advisors recommend for annuity placements; GBU meets that standard with a conservative, fully-reserved balance sheet built over more than a century |
| Defined Benefit Annuity | A single premium annuity designed to deliver guaranteed income structured like a traditional pension — payments you cannot outlive | For buyers whose primary goal is a reliable monthly paycheck in retirement that never stops, GBU’s Defined Benefit Annuity replaces the pension most private-sector workers no longer receive |
| Asset Guard FIA | Fixed indexed annuity that links interest to market index performance while keeping your principal fully protected — you benefit when markets rise, keep everything when they fall | For buyers who want more growth potential than a fixed rate provides but cannot accept stock market losses — the Asset Guard occupies the space between a MYGA and market exposure |
| Future Flex FIA | A flexible premium fixed indexed annuity that lets you contribute over time rather than requiring a single lump sum — indexed growth with downside protection | For buyers who want to build an indexed annuity position gradually — adding funds as they become available — rather than committing a single large deposit all at once |
| Asset Guard Fixed | Fixed growth annuity with liquidity features and flexible withdrawal provisions — guaranteed rate with built-in access to funds | For buyers who want the security of a guaranteed fixed rate but need more flexibility around accessing their money than a standard MYGA surrender schedule provides |
| Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity | Lock in a guaranteed fixed rate for 2, 3, 4, or 5 years — your principal cannot go down, your rate cannot be cut mid-term, and joint ownership is available for married couples | The 2-year term option is genuinely rare in the market; the 4-year term is also uncommon; and the joint ownership provision makes GBU’s MYGA especially useful for couples managing shared retirement assets |
| No Annual Fees | GBU charges no service or administrative fees on annuity products — the rate you earn is the rate you keep | Fees erode guaranteed returns quietly over time; GBU’s not-for-profit structure passes cost savings directly to members rather than to outside shareholders |
What Makes GBU Different From a Commercial Insurer
Most insurance companies are either publicly traded corporations answering to shareholders or privately held companies where profits flow to owners. GBU Financial Life is neither. As a fraternal benefit society organized as a not-for-profit member organization, the people who hold policies are the owners, and the financial gains stay within the membership rather than flowing to outside investors. That structure has a direct effect on your experience as an annuity buyer: no administrative fees, no shareholder dividend demands competing with policyholder returns, and a management team whose primary obligation is to the 65,000 members who depend on the organization. GBU also takes a notably conservative approach to reserving — AM Best has specifically noted that GBU fully reserves its annuity business, which is more conservative than required and provides a capital cushion beyond what the standard financial ratios show. That conservatism is exactly what long-term annuity holders need behind their guarantees. For buyers comparing GBU’s fraternal structure against Thrivent — the other major fraternal benefit society in the retirement market with significantly larger scale — our resource on Is Thrivent a Good Insurance Company covers the direct comparison, including Thrivent’s Christian membership requirement that GBU does not impose. For buyers focused on MYGA rates across the full A-rated market, our resource on best MYGA annuity rates covers where GBU stands against the broader competitive field on any given day.
The Full Product Lineup and Who Each Product Fits
GBU’s MYGA spans 2, 3, 4, and 5-year terms — a range that is broader than most MYGA carriers offer. The 2-year option is rare, the 4-year option is uncommon, and all terms include the option for joint ownership on the contract, which is particularly useful for married couples managing shared retirement savings. Understanding what you are actually buying when you purchase a MYGA — the principal protection mechanics, how interest credits, and what the surrender schedule means in practice — is covered in our resource on understanding multi-year guaranteed annuities. For buyers comparing GBU’s MYGA specifically against other A-rated fraternal and regional MYGA carriers, the Royal Neighbors MYGA, the Knighthead Life Staysail MYGA, the American National Palladium MYGA, the Ibexis MYGA Plus, the North American Guarantee Plus MYGA, and the Pacific Guardian Diamond Head MYGA are each worth a rate comparison on the specific term you are evaluating. One link per carrier per page does not do justice to the width of competition in the MYGA market — the right carrier on a given day depends on the exact term and deposit band being compared. The GBU Defined Benefit Annuity is the income-first product for buyers whose primary goal is a pension-like payment structure — a guaranteed monthly income that continues for life regardless of how long they live or how markets perform. For buyers evaluating immediate income options across the broader market, our resource on the best immediate annuity for monthly income places GBU’s income product in competitive context. The GBU Asset Guard FIA and GBU Future Flex FIA address the growth segment — indexed interest with principal protection, the former for single-premium buyers and the latter for those who want to contribute over time. Our resource on best fixed indexed annuities covers where GBU’s FIA lineup fits in the broader competitive landscape. The GBU Asset Guard Fixed adds a liquidity dimension to fixed growth — useful for buyers who want a guaranteed rate but need withdrawal flexibility beyond what a standard MYGA surrender schedule permits.
Who GBU Is Best Suited For
GBU’s strongest fit is the retirement saver who wants a conservative, A-rated carrier with a long operating history, no fee drag on their guaranteed returns, and a product lineup that covers income, accumulation, and indexed growth without requiring them to navigate a complex product shelf. The 130-year track record answers the durability question that most retirees care about most — will this company still be here in 20 years paying my income? For buyers rolling over a 401(k) or IRA into an annuity, the question of whether a short-term MYGA makes more sense than a longer commitment or an income product is covered in our resource on MYGA strategies for affluent individuals, which addresses the multi-carrier comparison approach that matters for larger balances. For buyers thinking through how GBU income fits alongside Social Security, our resource on how Social Security and annuities work together covers the timing and sequencing that most GBU buyers are navigating at the point of purchase. The withdrawal provisions on GBU products — what you can access without penalty and when — are covered in the context of the broader annuity market in our resource on annuity free withdrawal rules. For buyers evaluating GBU against Royal Neighbors of America — the other fraternal MYGA carrier with a comparable not-for-profit membership structure — our resource on Is Royal Neighbors a Good Insurance Company covers that direct comparison. And for buyers who want to understand what happens to a GBU annuity at death — how beneficiaries receive the value and what tax treatment applies — our resources on annuity beneficiary death benefits and how annuities are taxed cover both the inheritance mechanics and the tax picture that applies to GBU’s product types.
When to Compare GBU Against Alternatives
GBU Life is available in approximately 33 states — meaning a meaningful portion of buyers will find GBU is simply not licensed where they live. If your state is not covered, our annuity rate tools above connect you with A-rated alternatives across the full national market. For buyers in GBU’s footprint, the honest comparison question is always whether GBU’s rate on a given day is competitive enough against other A-rated alternatives to make it the best choice for the specific term and deposit amount in question. The no-fee structure helps GBU’s effective yield, but rate comparison still matters, and our resource on getting a second opinion on your annuity quote covers the validation process that makes sense before any annuity commitment. For buyers using non-qualified money — after-tax funds not in an IRA or 401(k) — our resource on non-qualified annuities covers the specific tax treatment that applies to GBU’s products in that context. For buyers thinking through the sequence-of-returns risk that motivates most safe-money annuity decisions, our resource on sequence of returns risk covers exactly why a guaranteed-return allocation protects retirement income even when the rest of a portfolio fluctuates. For buyers comparing GBU against Pacific Guardian — another A-rated carrier with a conservative regional profile and strong MYGA credentials — our resource on Is Pacific Guardian Life a Good Company covers that side-by-side. And for buyers whose retirement planning also involves long-term care decisions running alongside their annuity evaluation, our resource on how to buy long-term care insurance covers the parallel planning decision that affects how much guaranteed income you actually need your annuity to provide. For retirement savers still assessing how long existing accounts will last before an annuity makes sense, our resources on how long an IRA will last in retirement and how long a 401(k) will last in retirement provide the context that often precedes the decision to move safe money into a guaranteed vehicle.
Talk With an Advisor Today
Choose how you’d like to connect—call or message us, then book a time that works for you.
Schedule here:
calendly.com/jason-dibcompanies/diversified-quotes
Licensed in all 50 states • Fiduciary, family-owned since 1980
Frequently Asked Questions: Is GBU a Good Insurance Company?
What does GBU Life actually do for my retirement money?
GBU gives your safe retirement money a place to grow at competitive guaranteed rates — with no stock market risk, no annual administrative fees, and an A- financial strength rating backed by 130 years of paying obligations. The four product areas address different retirement goals. The MYGA locks in a fixed rate for a defined term so you know exactly what your balance will be at maturity. The Defined Benefit Annuity converts a lump sum into guaranteed monthly income that continues for life — a pension replacement for buyers who no longer have one from an employer. The Asset Guard FIA and Future Flex FIA link interest to market index performance with principal fully protected, so you benefit when markets rise and lose nothing when they fall. Across all products: interest compounds tax-deferred, no fees reduce your return, and your full account value passes to your named beneficiary at death. The no-fee structure is sustainable because GBU’s not-for-profit membership model passes financial efficiencies to policyholders rather than extracting them for outside shareholders. Our resource on annuity beneficiary death benefits covers how GBU’s death benefit provisions work in detail.
What is GBU’s financial strength rating and how long have they been around?
GBU Financial Life holds AM Best A- (Excellent) — the minimum rating most independent financial advisors recommend for annuity placements — and has maintained and grown into that rating over many years. The company backs that rating with $4.7 billion in assets, a $314 million surplus, and a solvency position that holds more than $107 in assets for every $100 in policyholder obligations. S&P rates GBU BBB+. The BBB gives it A+. The NAIC complaint ratio runs below the industry average, which means GBU generates fewer regulatory complaints than expected for a company of its size. GBU has operated continuously since 1892 — meaning it has been paying policyholder obligations through the Great Depression, World War II, the 2008 financial crisis, and every economic environment in between. AM Best has also specifically noted that GBU fully reserves its annuity business, which is a more conservative reserving practice than required by regulators and provides a capital cushion beyond what the standard financial ratios reflect. For context on what the A- means in the broader carrier landscape, our resource on what an AM Best rating means walks through the full tier framework that applies to GBU and every competing carrier.
What MYGA terms does GBU offer and what makes them stand out?
GBU’s MYGA is available in 2, 3, 4, and 5-year terms — a range that is broader than most carriers offer. The 2-year term is rare in the market and useful for buyers who want short-commitment protection without locking into a longer surrender schedule. The 4-year term is also uncommon — most carriers jump from 3-year directly to 5-year. GBU’s joint ownership option on the MYGA is a standout provision for married couples who want the contract to reflect shared ownership rather than naming one spouse as owner with the other as beneficiary — a distinction that matters for estate planning and account access. Standard provisions apply across all terms: your principal cannot go down, your guaranteed rate cannot be cut mid-term, interest compounds tax-deferred, and a penalty-free withdrawal provision gives access to a portion of your account value annually without triggering surrender charges. For buyers building a retirement income strategy using multiple MYGA terms at different carriers, our resource on laddering fixed annuities for retirement income covers the approach where GBU’s broad term range is especially useful. For buyers who want to understand what happens to CDs and MYGAs side by side, our resource on transferring a CD into an annuity covers that comparison directly.
Do I have to join GBU as a member? What does membership include?
Purchasing any GBU annuity or life insurance product automatically makes you a member — there is no separate enrollment step, membership fee, or religious affiliation requirement. Membership is simply what you become when you place your money with GBU, and it comes with access to GBU’s fraternal benefit programs at no additional cost: scholarship programs for members and their families, charitable giving tools that let you direct contributions to causes you care about, community events organized through GBU’s local district system, and Operation Reach Out — the program that ships care packages to military personnel serving overseas. These benefits are funded by GBU’s not-for-profit structure and have been part of the organization’s mission since 1892. For buyers who want to participate in GBU’s community activities without purchasing an insurance or annuity product, a social membership option is also available. Importantly, GBU has no religious faith requirement for membership — it is open to buyers from any background, unlike Thrivent which requires a Christian faith affiliation. For buyers comparing GBU to Thrivent on product terms and financial strength alongside the membership structure, our resource on Is Thrivent a Good Insurance Company covers that comparison directly.
Is GBU Life available in my state?
GBU Life’s annuity products are available in approximately 33 states — a regional footprint that reflects the company’s fraternal roots and history rather than a national commercial distribution strategy. Roughly one in three buyers reading this page may find that GBU is not licensed in their state. Before spending time on a rate comparison or requesting an illustration, confirm that GBU is approved where you live. If it is not, our annuity rate comparison tools above cover A-rated alternatives available nationally, including the full range of MYGA terms and income products. For buyers in GBU’s footprint who want to compare GBU’s MYGA against another A-rated regional carrier with a similarly conservative profile, our resource on Is Pacific Guardian Life a Good Company covers that specific comparison. The state guaranty association provides an additional safety net behind GBU’s own financial strength — our resource on state guaranty association protections covers what that safety net means for annuity holders in each state where GBU operates.
About the Author:
Jason Stolz, CLTC, CRPC, DIA, CAA and Chief Underwriter at Diversified Insurance Brokers (NPN 20471358), is a senior insurance and retirement professional with more than 25 years of real-world experience helping individuals, families, and business owners protect their income, assets, and long-term financial stability. As a long-time partner of the nationally licensed independent agency Diversified Insurance Brokers, Jason provides trusted guidance across multiple specialties—including fixed and indexed annuities, long-term care planning, personal and business disability insurance, life insurance solutions, Group Health, Travel Medical and Evacuation Insurance, and short-term health coverage. Diversified Insurance Brokers maintains active contracts with over 100 highly rated insurance carriers, ensuring clients have access to a broad and competitive marketplace.
His practical, education-first approach has earned recognition in publications such as VoyageATL, as well as his agency's featured coverage in Kiplinger— highlighting his commitment to financial clarity and client-focused planning. Drawing on deep product knowledge and years of hands-on field experience, Jason helps clients evaluate carriers, compare strategies, and build retirement and protection plans that are both secure and cost-efficient. Visitors who want to explore current annuity rates and compare options across multiple insurers can also use this annuity quote and comparison tool.
Review More Carrier Reviews: Browse our complete Burial Insurance Company Reviews — covering Mutual of Omaha, Americo, Globe Life, Colonial Penn, and more burial insurance carriers.
Editorial Standards: Diversified Insurance Brokers maintains rigorous editorial standards to ensure accuracy, clarity, and independence in all content. Learn more about our editorial standards and commitment to transparency.
