Best 3 Year Annuity Rate
Best 3 Year Annuity Rate
Jason Stolz CLTC, CRPC, DIA, CAA
The best 3-year annuity rate marks an important threshold in the fixed annuity marketplace: it is the first common MYGA term where the declared rate consistently breaks through the 6.00% level in today’s market, and it is the first term where a buyer genuinely transitions from short-term parking to medium-term rate commitment. The rate improvement from 2-year to 3-year is meaningful — today’s best 2-year rate is 5.25%, while today’s best 3-year rate is 6.00%, a 0.75 percentage point improvement per year. On $100,000, that means approximately $750 more in guaranteed interest per year, or approximately $2,350 more over the full 3-year term compared to a 2-year MYGA at today’s rates. The jump to 6% also has practical significance beyond the arithmetic: at 6.00%, a 3-year MYGA is generating meaningful guaranteed returns that compete effectively with moderate-risk alternatives — making the case that adding market exposure to achieve better returns requires the market to outperform by enough to justify the added volatility. Two observations about the 3-year carrier table are worth noting before any product selection: first, unlike the 2-year tier where A-rated and A- rated carriers appeared at competitive rates, the 3-year tier’s rate leaders are entirely in the B-range of the AM Best scale (B, B-, B+, B++). Second, the majority of 3-year carriers in today’s table list “None” for penalty-free withdrawal — meaning buyers who choose the 3-year term for the rate improvement should be genuinely prepared to hold through the full 36-month surrender period without needing the principal. These two characteristics — B-range carrier concentration and limited penalty-free withdrawal — define the 3-year tier’s specific trade-off profile and should be clearly understood before making a commitment. For the full market overview across all terms, our current fixed annuity rates page and highest guaranteed annuity rates resource provide the complete context.
The 3-year MYGA is where many conservative savers make their first genuinely medium-term commitment — stepping up from the 1-year and 2-year terms they used for transitional or near-term capital management into a commitment where the primary goal is rate optimization over a defined multi-year period. This transition is significant because it changes the buyer’s primary evaluation criterion: at 1-year and 2-year terms, liquidity flexibility is often the primary driver (hence the A-rated carriers that compete at those terms with 10% penalty-free withdrawal options). At 3 years, the buyer is typically accepting more limited liquidity in exchange for a demonstrably better rate, which means the key evaluation shifts to maximizing the declared rate from a carrier whose financial profile is adequate for a 36-month relationship. The carriers that lead the 3-year tier — Sentinel Security and Mountain Life at 6.00% — are the same regional carriers that lead other MYGA terms across the rate table, with their investment portfolio positioning enabling higher yields than A-rated national carriers can sustain at the same term. Understanding this structure clearly — and explicitly deciding whether the rate leadership of the B-range carriers is worth the carrier quality trade-off for a 36-month commitment — is the productive starting point for any 3-year MYGA evaluation. Our resource on best short-term MYGA annuities covers the 1-to-3-year spectrum and how the 3-year sits at the upper end of that short-term tier, and our guide on whether annuities are worth it provides the foundational value proposition analysis that helps buyers determine whether any MYGA structure is the right vehicle for their conservative savings.
The 3-year term also plays a specific role in the most common MYGA ladder configurations. In a standard fixed annuity ladder, the 3-year rung creates a maturity window in the third year — a decision point that typically falls at a financially meaningful moment for buyers who synchronize their ladder with retirement planning milestones. A buyer who retires in three years and builds a ladder today might structure the 3-year rung as the component that matures at the planned retirement date, providing principal plus three years of compounded guaranteed interest at exactly the moment when capital is needed for income conversion, large purchases, or repositioning into a longer-term income structure. The 3-year’s position at the junction of short-term flexibility and medium-term rate commitment makes it one of the most functionally useful rungs in a MYGA ladder — not because it is universally superior to adjacent terms, but because its specific maturity timeline aligns naturally with common 3-year planning horizons. The importance of matching MYGA term length to the buyer’s actual planning decision dates — rather than selecting on rate alone — is the consistent theme across the full term spectrum, and the 3-year term exemplifies why this matters for conservative annuity buyers at every stage of retirement planning.
Ensure you are receiving the absolute top rates
Current Fixed Annuity Rates
Compare today’s best fixed annuity rates from top carriers.
View Current RatesCurrent Bonus Annuity Rates
See which annuities offer the highest upfront bonus today.
View Bonus RatesRequest an Annuity Quote
Submit our annuity request form to get personalized rate options.
Quote Request FormLifetime Income Calculator
Use our calculator to see how much guaranteed income your annuity can provide.
What Is a 3-Year Fixed Annuity — And Why the 6% Threshold Matters
A 3-year fixed annuity is a MYGA that declares a guaranteed interest rate for exactly 36 months. The declared rate applies to the full accumulation value every year of the term — there is no index, no cap, no spread, no variable crediting, and no year in which the credited rate can be reduced. Principal is protected from any market loss: the balance on day one of year three is exactly the balance on day one of year one plus two full years of compounding at the declared rate. Interest accumulates tax-deferred inside the contract for non-qualified money — no annual 1099 is generated until funds are withdrawn. At the end of month 36, a maturity window opens (typically 30 days) providing penalty-free access to the full accumulated value for withdrawal, renewal, or repositioning. The 6.00% rate available at today’s 3-year tier is meaningful because it places the guaranteed return from a principal-protected, tax-deferred instrument in a genuinely competitive range against moderate-risk alternatives. A $100,000 deposit at 6.00% for 3 years grows to approximately $119,100 at maturity — $19,100 in guaranteed, principal-protected, tax-deferred growth over 36 months. For a buyer allocating conservative retirement savings, this outcome — precise, calculable, immune from market risk — is exactly what the MYGA structure is designed to deliver.
💰 Best 3-Year Annuity Rates (as of June 2026)
The table below shows today’s five best 3-year MYGA options from competitive carriers, including their AM Best financial strength ratings and penalty-free withdrawal provisions. Note that most carriers at the 3-year tier do not offer penalty-free withdrawals during the surrender period — a distinguishing characteristic of this term compared to the 2-year tier where multiple carriers offered 10% annual free access. Buyers who need any access to funds during the 3-year term should prioritize Mountain Life (the only carrier with a penalty-free allowance) or reduce their commitment to a 2-year term with better liquidity provisions.
| Company | AM Best Rating | Current Rate | Penalty-Free Withdrawal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sentinel Security | B | 6.00% | None |
| Mountain Life | B- | 6.00% | 5% First Year |
| Wichita National Life Insurance Company | B+ | 5.85% | None |
| Atlantic Coast Life | B | 5.79% | None |
| Farmer Life | B++ | 5.50% | None |
Rates are subject to change and may vary by state, age, and deposit size. Some of the highest rates come from carriers with B-range ratings. A-rated alternatives are available at modestly lower declared rates — contact us to include those in any comparison for your situation.
Compare Annuity Income by Investment Amount
See estimated income examples for different annuity investment amounts to understand how payouts can scale.
The Critical Characteristic of the 3-Year Tier — No Penalty-Free Access for Most Carriers
The most important practical distinction of the 3-year carrier table compared to the 2-year tier is the near-universal absence of penalty-free withdrawal provisions. At the 2-year tier, multiple carriers (Axonic, Oceanview, GBU) offered 10% annual penalty-free access — giving buyers meaningful liquidity during the 24-month commitment. At the 3-year tier, four of the five carriers listed above offer zero penalty-free withdrawals during the 36-month term: Sentinel Security (B, 6.00%), Wichita National (B+, 5.85%), Atlantic Coast Life (B, 5.79%), and Farmer Life (B++, 5.50%) all have “None” listed. Only Mountain Life (B-, 6.00%) offers any penalty-free access — 5% in the first year only, which means up to $5,000 per year on a $100,000 deposit but only during year one, with no penalty-free access in years two and three. This liquidity limitation is the most important thing a buyer considering the 3-year tier must understand before selecting a carrier and term. A buyer who commits to a 3-year MYGA with a “None” penalty-free withdrawal provision is genuinely committing to hold through the full 36 months — any access above zero during the term will trigger surrender charges. If the buyer has any realistic possibility of needing access to a portion of these funds during the 36-month period, the correct response is to either select the 3-year Mountain Life product (which provides limited first-year access), reduce the commitment to a 2-year MYGA where liquidity provisions are more generous, or structure a ladder where only a portion of total savings is committed at 3 years and the remainder stays in shorter-term positions. Our comprehensive resource on annuity surrender charges and MVA covers the mechanics of what happens when withdrawals exceed allowable amounts, and our resource on annuity surrender charges explained provides the buyer-facing explanation of these provisions across different carrier designs.
Reading the 3-Year Carrier Table — Rate, Quality, and Withdrawal Context Together
The five carriers in today’s 3-year rate table span a range of AM Best ratings from B- (Mountain Life) to B++ (Farmer Life), with all carriers in the B-range. This is a notable departure from the 2-year tier, which included A-rated and A- rated options within 0.30% of the rate leader. At the 3-year term, A-rated carriers fall further behind on rate — their investment portfolio positioning does not generate enough additional yield to close the gap competitively at 36 months, and the B-range carriers lead the tier. For buyers who prioritize A-rated carrier financial strength at the 3-year term, A-rated alternatives are available at modestly lower declared rates (typically 5.25%–5.50% range) — still substantially above the 2-year A-rated alternatives and competitive in absolute terms. The rate premium for accepting B-range carrier quality at 3 years is larger than at 2 years, making the carrier quality trade-off more explicit. At Sentinel Security (B, 6.00%) vs. a hypothetical A-rated 3-year at 5.35%, the differential is 0.65% per year — approximately $1,950 per $100,000 over the full 3-year term. Whether that $1,950 per $100,000 is worth the B vs. A carrier quality difference is the buyer’s specific judgment based on their premium size, state guaranty association coverage limits, and overall comfort with the carrier’s financial profile. Farmer Life (B++, 5.50%) provides the strongest AM Best rating in the table at a 0.50% rate cost versus the leader — and is the only carrier in the table with the best-in-class B-range rating for buyers who want the highest available B-range rating at a meaningful rate.
The 3-Year as the CD Replacement Inflection Point
The 3-year MYGA at 6.00% represents the most compelling CD replacement argument in the current market. Most national bank 3-year CDs offer declared rates in the 4.00%–4.75% range — a gap of 1.25%–2.00% below today’s best 3-year MYGA rate. On $200,000, that rate gap represents $2,500–$4,000 per year in additional guaranteed interest, or $7,500–$12,000 over the full 3-year term. Beyond the rate differential, the tax deferral advantage of the MYGA provides further after-tax yield improvement for non-qualified (after-tax) money. A CD at 4.50% generates $9,000 per year in taxable interest on $200,000 — for a buyer in the 24% federal tax bracket, that creates $2,160 in annual income tax, reducing the effective after-tax annual yield to approximately 3.42%. The 3-year MYGA at 6.00% generates no annual 1099 — all $12,000 of annual interest accumulates tax-deferred without any annual tax cost. The full after-tax comparison over 3 years between a CD at 4.50% and a MYGA at 6.00% — accounting for both the rate differential and the tax deferral — can produce a difference of $15,000–$20,000 or more on $200,000 over the full term for buyers in higher tax brackets. Our detailed resource on fixed annuities vs. CDs provides the full after-tax mechanics across different tax brackets, and our resource on non-qualified annuities covers the complete tax treatment for after-tax funded 3-year MYGAs. For the broader context on tax-deferred annuity strategies, our dedicated resource covers how the deferral advantage compounds across multi-year holding periods at different tax brackets.
The 3-Year vs. 4-Year Decision — What One More Year of Commitment Costs and Provides
The most common comparison for buyers settled on the short-to-medium term is between the 3-year and 4-year annuity rate. Today’s best 4-year MYGA rate is 6.05% — just 0.05% above the best 3-year rate of 6.00%. This means the rate case for the 4-year over the 3-year is exceptionally thin in today’s market: one additional year of surrender commitment earns approximately $50 more per $100,000 per year in guaranteed interest. Over the full 4-year term, a 4-year MYGA at 6.05% produces approximately $26,900 in guaranteed interest on $100,000, while a 3-year MYGA at 6.00% produces approximately $19,100 — a difference of $7,800, but only because the 4-year term is one year longer (so the comparison is not year-for-year but total-term). On a per-year basis, the 4-year earns essentially the same as the 3-year at current rates. The practical implication is clear: unless the buyer’s planning horizon genuinely extends to 48 months, there is almost no rate incentive to commit to the 4-year term over the 3-year in today’s market. The correct choice between 3-year and 4-year at today’s rate levels is almost entirely driven by whether the buyer’s actual holding horizon is 36 months or 48 months — not by the rate differential, which is negligible. Similarly, the comparison to the 2-year annuity rate shows a clearer trade-off: the 3-year earns 0.75% more per year than the best 2-year rate, which is a meaningful improvement (approximately $750 per $100,000 per year) for buyers who can genuinely commit to 36 months.
Principal Protection and Tax-Deferred Growth in the 3-Year Context
The principal protection and tax deferral features of a 3-year MYGA are identical in structure to any other MYGA but carry specific additional significance at the 3-year term because of the longer exposure to potential economic volatility. A buyer committing to a 3-year MYGA today is locking principal protection through June 2029 — a period during which equity markets, real estate, and interest rates may move in unpredictable directions. The MYGA’s principal protection guarantee is unconditional: regardless of what markets do during those 36 months, the accumulated value cannot decline below premium plus credited interest. This is categorically different from bond funds (which lose value when rates rise), equity investments (which decline with market corrections), and money markets (which can see rate compression that reduces yield at any time). The tax deferral’s three-year scope makes it meaningfully more impactful than at 1-year terms: for a non-qualified buyer in the 24% federal bracket with $250,000 in a 3-year MYGA at 6.00%, avoiding three consecutive annual 1099 events preserves approximately $10,800 in after-tax dollars versus a comparable CD over the term — money that stays in the account compounding at the declared rate rather than being distributed as tax payments. For buyers evaluating whether the 3-year MYGA’s combination of principal protection, guaranteed rate, and tax deferral is worth accepting versus pursuing market returns, our resource on whether annuities are worth it provides the candid analysis that helps buyers make this determination for their specific situation.
The 3-Year MYGA in a Ladder Strategy — Where the Midpoint Rung Earns Its Place
In a fixed annuity ladder, the 3-year rung creates the first genuinely medium-term maturity window — a decision point in year three that is far enough away to capture competitive rates while close enough to provide meaningful future liquidity on a definable timeline. A practical ladder for a conservative saver with $300,000 might allocate $100,000 each to a 2-year MYGA at 5.25%, a 3-year MYGA at 6.00%, and a 5-year MYGA at 6.35%. The 2-year matures in 2028, providing the first scheduled liquidity window. The 3-year matures in 2029, providing the second. The 5-year matures in 2031, providing the third. The ladder captures today’s rates at three different points on the yield curve, creating three independent decision points without concentrating all reinvestment risk at a single future date. The 3-year rung’s specific contribution to this ladder is the middle maturity window: its 6.00% rate is significantly above the 2-year tier while its 36-month commitment creates a structured decision point in 2029 at which the buyer can evaluate the rate environment and decide whether to renew into another 3-year MYGA, roll into a 5-year at whatever rate is then available, or convert to a different structure entirely. This flexibility at the 2029 decision point — combined with the protected growth at 6.00% through that date — is the specific value the 3-year rung contributes to the ladder architecture. The 3-year also serves as the transition point in the short-term MYGA universe: below it are the 1-year and 2-year terms that prioritize near-term liquidity, and above it are the 7-year, 8-year, 9-year, and 10-year terms that prioritize long-term rate lock over near-term flexibility.
Who Specifically Benefits From a 3-Year MYGA
The 3-year MYGA buyer profile is distinct from both the 1-to-2-year buyer (who prioritizes flexibility) and the 5-to-10-year buyer (who prioritizes maximum rate lock). The typical 3-year buyer has a genuine 36-month planning horizon — a specific financial decision or event that is expected in approximately three years — and wants to capture the 6.00% rate for the full period without the extended commitment of a 5-year contract. Specific buyer profiles at this term include: buyers with maturing 3-year CDs who are rolling into a MYGA to capture the superior rate and tax deferral advantages; pre-retirees who expect to retire in 3 years and want guaranteed, principal-protected growth on their conservative savings through the retirement date; buyers implementing a 3-5-7 ladder where the 3-year rung provides the first maturity window with a competitive rate; buyers positioning funds from a 401(k) or IRA rollover in a 3-year holding position while finalizing their long-term retirement income strategy; and buyers who completed a 2-year MYGA and are rolling into a 3-year at maturity to capture the improved rate now that their planning horizon has stabilized around a 3-year timeframe. For buyers who are positioning rollover assets from IRA or 401(k) accounts, our resource on what to do with an IRA after retiring provides the broader decision framework for the rollover decision that precedes the 3-year MYGA placement. For buyers who eventually want guaranteed lifetime income and are using the 3-year MYGA as an accumulation bridge, our resource on best fixed indexed annuities with lifetime income riders covers the income structures most commonly selected at 3-year MYGA maturity.
Understanding Market Value Adjustments on 3-Year Annuities
Some 3-year MYGA contracts include a Market Value Adjustment provision that affects the value received on any surrenders or withdrawals above the penalty-free allowance (which for most 3-year carriers is zero). Understanding the MVA mechanics before selecting any 3-year MYGA is important because the combination of “None” penalty-free withdrawal plus an MVA provision creates a particularly restrictive liquidity environment: any mid-term exit above zero not only triggers surrender charges but may also be subject to an interest rate adjustment based on how rates have moved since the contract was issued. For 3-year contracts with no penalty-free access and an MVA, the practical advice is straightforward: do not commit to this term unless you are genuinely prepared to hold through month 36 under any realistic scenario. The MVA is irrelevant for buyers who hold through the full term — it only applies to early exits. But for buyers with any uncertainty about their ability to hold 36 months without accessing the full principal, confirming the MVA provisions (and whether they apply to the specific 3-year product under consideration) is a required pre-purchase step. Products with no MVA at the same rate level — where they exist — eliminate this variable from the analysis for buyers who prioritize the maximum early-exit simplicity.
The 3-Year in the Context of the Full Rate Spectrum
The 3-year MYGA sits at a specific and important position within the broader MYGA rate spectrum. Below it, the 1-year (4.15%) and 2-year (5.25%) terms provide rate improvement in increments as commitment increases. The 3-year (6.00%) represents the first term where rates break clearly through the 6% barrier — a meaningful level that makes the rate case for the 3-year distinctly stronger than the 2-year versus the 1-year comparison. Above it, the rate improvements from 3-year to 4-year (6.05%) to 5-year (6.35%) are smaller in proportional terms than the jump from 2-year to 3-year, which means the 3-year captures most of the available rate improvement while maintaining a relatively shorter commitment horizon. This position — capturing the biggest rate step-up from the short-term tier while remaining in the short-term commitment zone — is what makes the 3-year MYGA frequently the most attractive term for buyers who are willing to commit beyond 24 months but not beyond 36 months. For buyers whose planning allows for 5-year commitments, the 5-year rate of 6.35% provides a meaningful additional 0.35% per year in guaranteed interest. For buyers whose planning is truly bounded at 36 months, the 3-year at 6.00% is the correct terminus of the rate-capture journey for their specific horizon. Our resource on the highest guaranteed annuity rates provides the complete market view across all MYGA terms for buyers who want to evaluate the full spectrum before selecting their specific commitment point.
Related Pages — Explore Additional Annuity Terms and Planning Resources
Request a Personalized 3-Year Quote
Receive customized comparisons from top-rated carriers based on your deposit and timeline — including both B-rated and A-rated carrier options with full surrender and MVA details for each carrier.
Talk With an Advisor Today
Choose how you’d like to connect—call or message us, then book a time that works for you.
Schedule here:
calendly.com/jason-dibcompanies/diversified-quotes
Licensed in all 50 states • Fiduciary, family-owned since 1980
FAQs: Best 3-Year Annuity Rate
What is the best 3-year annuity rate right now?
Today’s best 3-year MYGA rate is 6.00%, available from two carriers: Sentinel Security (B rated, no penalty-free withdrawal) and Mountain Life (B- rated, 5% penalty-free in year one only). The next tier includes Wichita National Life (B+ rated) at 5.85% with no penalty-free access, Atlantic Coast Life (B rated) at 5.79% with no penalty-free access, and Farmer Life (B++ rated) at 5.50% with no penalty-free access. All five carriers in today’s 3-year table are in the B-range of the AM Best scale — A-rated alternatives are available at modestly lower rates (approximately 5.25%–5.50% range). Rates change frequently; confirm a live quote for your specific state, age, and deposit amount before purchasing.
Can I access funds during the 3-year term?
The access provisions differ significantly across the five carriers in today’s 3-year table. Four of the five (Sentinel Security, Wichita National, Atlantic Coast Life, and Farmer Life) list “None” for penalty-free withdrawals — meaning no penalty-free access during the entire 36-month term; any withdrawal triggers surrender charges. Mountain Life (6.00%, B-) allows 5% penalty-free access in the first year only, with no penalty-free access in years two and three. For buyers who expect to need any access to funds during the 3-year term, Mountain Life is the only carrier in the table that accommodates it (up to $5,000 per year on $100,000 in year one). For buyers who need more meaningful liquidity during the term, the 2-year tier offers better liquidity provisions at a modestly lower rate.
Do 3-year MYGAs usually pay more than 1–2 year terms?
Yes — and in today’s market, the 3-year rate improvement over shorter terms is the most significant step-up on the MYGA yield curve. Today’s best 3-year rate (6.00%) is 1.85 percentage points above the best 1-year rate (4.15%) and 0.75 percentage points above the best 2-year rate (5.25%). The jump from 2-year to 3-year is the most impactful single-term step in the current market because it crosses the 6% threshold — a level where the guaranteed return from a principal-protected annuity becomes genuinely competitive with moderate-risk alternatives. Above the 3-year tier, the rate improvements are smaller: 3-year to 4-year is only 0.05%, and 3-year to 5-year is 0.35%. This means the 3-year captures most of the available rate improvement while maintaining a commitment shorter than the 5-to-10-year tier.
What happens at maturity after 3 years?
At the end of the 36-month term, a penalty-free maturity window opens — typically 30 days — during which the buyer can take any action without surrender charges: (1) Withdraw the full accumulated value — original premium plus three years of compounded interest; (2) Renew into a new 3-year MYGA at then-current declared rates; (3) Roll into a different term MYGA (4-year, 5-year, 7-year, etc.) at then-current rates; or (4) Convert to a different annuity structure such as a fixed indexed annuity or lifetime income product. For qualified account money (IRA, 401k), the rollover continues tax-free as a carrier-to-carrier transfer. For non-qualified money, it can be structured as a 1035 exchange to preserve tax-deferred status. If no action is taken during the maturity window, most contracts auto-renew at the carrier’s then-current 3-year declared rate.
Are 3-year fixed annuities safe?
Yes — fixed annuities protect principal from market loss, lock the declared rate for the full 3-year term, and are backed by state insurance regulatory oversight including statutory reserve requirements. All five carriers in today’s 3-year table are licensed insurers meeting these regulatory standards. State guaranty associations provide protection within applicable limits (typically $250,000 per insurer per state for fixed annuities) for all licensed carriers. The 3-year table is notable for containing only B-range carriers at the top rate levels — no A-rated carriers appear at 6.00% at this term. Buyers with large premium amounts above state guaranty association limits should evaluate whether the rate advantage of the B-rated leaders is appropriate relative to their exposure above protection limits, or whether A-rated alternatives at lower rates are more appropriate for their premium size.
How does a 3-year MYGA compare to a 3-year CD?
Today’s best 3-year MYGA rate (6.00%) significantly exceeds the best 3-year national bank CD rates (typically 4.00%–4.75%). On $200,000, the rate differential produces approximately $2,500–$4,000 per year in additional guaranteed interest. For non-qualified (after-tax) money, the MYGA adds a meaningful additional advantage: CD interest generates an annual 1099 taxable at ordinary income rates, while MYGA interest accumulates tax-deferred with no annual tax event. For buyers in the 24% federal tax bracket, this deferral adds approximately 1.44% to the effective after-tax yield advantage (versus the stated rate gap of 1.25%–2.00%). CDs retain the FDIC insurance advantage — government-backed protection up to $250,000 per depositor. MYGAs are backed by the insurance carrier and state guaranty associations within applicable limits. For the full after-tax mechanics, our dedicated resource on fixed annuities vs. CDs provides the complete comparison.
Why are no A-rated carriers in the top 3-year rate tier?
A-rated and A- rated carriers appear competitively at the 2-year tier (Axonic A-, Oceanview A, GBU A- all within 0.30% of the rate leader). At the 3-year tier, A-rated carriers fall further behind in declared rate because their investment portfolio positioning — concentrated in higher-rated investment-grade bonds that generate lower but more stable yields — does not produce enough additional investment income at the 36-month term to close the rate gap against B-range carriers that accept more portfolio risk for higher yields. A-rated 3-year MYGA alternatives are available at approximately 5.25%–5.50% — still competitive in absolute terms and meaningfully above 2-year A-rated options, but 0.50%–0.75% below the rate leaders in today’s 3-year table. For buyers who prioritize A-rated carrier financial strength, the rate sacrifice at 3 years is real but the alternatives remain genuinely competitive compared to CDs and other conservative instruments.
Should I choose 3-year or 4-year at today’s rates?
In today’s market, the 3-year vs. 4-year comparison is almost entirely a timeline decision rather than a rate decision. The best 4-year MYGA rate (6.05%) is only 0.05% above the best 3-year rate (6.00%) — an effectively negligible rate difference that produces approximately $50 per year in additional guaranteed interest per $100,000. There is almost no rate incentive to commit to the 4-year term over the 3-year in today’s market. The correct choice is driven by your actual planning horizon: if you genuinely will not need the full principal for 48 months, the 4-year MYGA provides the same 6% rate range with one additional year of commitment (and one additional year of protection from rate reinvestment risk). If your horizon is 36 months, the 3-year is the better structural match at essentially the same rate.
About the Author:
Jason Stolz, CLTC, CRPC, DIA, CAA and Chief Underwriter at Diversified Insurance Brokers (NPN 20471358), is a senior insurance and retirement professional with more than 25 years of real-world experience helping individuals, families, and business owners protect their income, assets, and long-term financial stability. As a long-time partner of the nationally licensed independent agency Diversified Insurance Brokers, Jason provides trusted guidance across multiple specialties—including fixed and indexed annuities, long-term care planning, personal and business disability insurance, life insurance solutions, Group Health, Travel Medical and Evacuation Insurance, and short-term health coverage. Diversified Insurance Brokers maintains active contracts with over 100 highly rated insurance carriers, ensuring clients have access to a broad and competitive marketplace.
His practical, education-first approach has earned recognition in publications such as VoyageATL, as well as his agency's featured coverage in Kiplinger— highlighting his commitment to financial clarity and client-focused planning. Drawing on deep product knowledge and years of hands-on field experience, Jason helps clients evaluate carriers, compare strategies, and build retirement and protection plans that are both secure and cost-efficient. Visitors who want to explore current annuity rates and compare options across multiple insurers can also use this annuity quote and comparison tool.
Explore More Annuity Options: Browse our complete guide to Current Annuity Rates — covering current fixed, bonus, MYGA & income annuity rates by term from top carriers from 100+ carriers.
Editorial Standards: Diversified Insurance Brokers maintains rigorous editorial standards to ensure accuracy, clarity, and independence in all content. Learn more about our editorial standards and commitment to transparency.
