How 1035 Exchanges Work in Annuity Planning
How 1035 Exchanges Work in Annuity Planning
As retirement approaches and markets evolve, your financial strategy must have the flexibility to adjust without creating unnecessary tax consequences. One of the most powerful yet underutilized tools available to annuity owners is the IRS-approved 1035 exchange. A 1035 exchange allows you to transfer funds directly from one annuity contract to another without triggering a taxable event, preserving your tax-deferred status while potentially upgrading your benefits. For retirees holding older contracts with lower interest rates, outdated crediting methods, limited income options, or high internal costs, this provision can be transformative. Instead of surrendering an annuity, recognizing taxable gains, and starting over, a properly executed exchange allows you to reposition those funds into a more competitive product. Many contracts issued years ago were built in entirely different interest rate environments. Today’s marketplace may offer improved features such as stronger guaranteed rates, enhanced income riders, upfront bonuses, or more flexible withdrawal provisions. Reviewing current annuity rates can help determine whether your existing contract remains competitive or if an upgrade deserves serious evaluation.
Ensure you are receiving the absolute top rates
Current Fixed Annuity Rates
Compare today’s best fixed annuity rates from top carriers.
Current Bonus Annuity Rates
See which annuities offer the highest upfront bonus today.
Request an Annuity Quote
Submit our annuity request form to get personalized rate options.
Lifetime Income Calculator
Use our calculator to see how much guaranteed income your annuity can provide.
1035 Exchange vs. Surrender vs. Keep and Wait: The Core Decision Framework
| Feature | 1035 Exchange | Surrender and Repurchase | Keep Current Contract |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tax Treatment | No taxable event — gains transfer intact with the cost basis. Tax deferral is preserved throughout. The exchange is IRS-approved under IRC Section 1035. | Fully taxable event — all gains in excess of cost basis are recognized as ordinary income in the year of surrender. No capital gains treatment. For large accumulated contracts, this can be a substantial tax bill. | No tax event — tax deferral continues unchanged. However, the ongoing cost of underperformance, suboptimal crediting, or missing income features is a continuing opportunity cost that is invisible on any tax return. |
| Cost Basis Treatment | Cost basis transfers intact to the new contract — the accumulated gain remains deferred and the original after-tax investment is preserved for future exclusion ratio calculations on non-qualified annuities. | Cost basis is eliminated — all gains are recognized and taxed. The new contract’s cost basis starts fresh at the full purchase price, but the taxes paid reduce the net amount available to invest. | Cost basis unchanged — continues to accumulate without recognition. No change to the exclusion ratio on existing non-qualified contracts. |
| Surrender Charges | Still apply if within the surrender period of the original contract — a 1035 exchange does not waive surrender charges. Free withdrawal provisions may reduce the impact. The analysis must weigh charges against the long-term benefit of improved terms. | Apply in full — on top of the taxable gain recognition. Surrender charges on top of ordinary income taxation can make early surrender extremely costly in the first few years of a contract. | No surrender charges — you avoid all penalties by staying. However, the opportunity cost of remaining in an underperforming contract may exceed what the surrender charges would have cost over the same period. |
| Access to Improved Features | Full access — the exchange positions the accumulated value into a new contract with current market terms, stronger crediting rates, improved income riders, or better structural design. | Full access — same ability to access current market terms, but the net amount to invest is reduced by taxes and surrender charges. A smaller starting base reduces the long-term compounding advantage. | None — you remain in the existing contract with its existing features, rates, and limitations. If the contract has rolled to a low renewal rate or lacks income riders you now need, those limitations persist. |
| Process Complexity | Moderate — requires carrier-to-carrier transfer (funds cannot pass through a personal account), completion of Section 1035 exchange forms, and coordinated application process. Typically takes 30 to 60 days to complete. | Simple — surrender the existing contract for the cash value minus surrender charges, receive a check, pay taxes, and purchase a new contract. No forms requiring carrier coordination, but the tax consequence is immediate. | None — no action required. Simplest short-term path but may require a deliberate re-evaluation decision to confirm the inaction is based on analysis rather than inertia. |
| Best For | Annuity owners with significant accumulated gains who want to upgrade to better rates, income features, or a different product type without triggering taxation. Ideal when the improvement in the new contract outweighs any remaining surrender charges. | Situations with minimal accumulated gain (small taxable event), where the exchange process is not practical, or where the annuity is being repositioned to a non-annuity product type that does not qualify for 1035 treatment. | When the existing contract remains competitive, when surrender charges are prohibitive, when the contract has unique features that cannot be replicated, or when a structured review confirms the current contract is the best available option. |
The IRS Rules Behind Section 1035 — What Qualifies
A 1035 exchange derives its authority from Internal Revenue Code Section 1035, which allows certain tax-free exchanges of insurance and annuity contracts. The IRS permits three categories of exchange: life insurance to life insurance, life insurance to annuity, and annuity to annuity. Annuity-to-life insurance exchanges are not permitted under Section 1035. For the exchange to qualify for tax-free treatment, two conditions must be satisfied. First, the transaction must be a direct carrier-to-carrier transfer — the funds cannot pass through the policyholder’s personal bank account or be paid as a check made out to the policyholder. If funds are received by the policyholder at any point during the transfer, the transaction is treated as a taxable distribution regardless of intent. Second, the exchange must involve a like-or-lesser product category — specifically, you cannot use a 1035 to exchange an annuity into a life insurance policy. Understanding how annuities are taxed provides the broader framework for why these preservation rules matter — gains inside annuities compound without annual taxation but become ordinary income when distributed, making the ability to defer that recognition through a 1035 exchange genuinely valuable for contracts with significant accumulated gains.
When a 1035 Exchange Makes Financial Sense
A 1035 exchange is particularly valuable for individuals who purchased annuities during low-rate periods or who originally selected contracts that no longer align with their retirement objectives. For example, some older fixed annuities may have rolled into minimal renewal rates after their initial guarantee period expired. Others may lack lifetime income features that have since become central to retirement income planning. In addition, indexed annuities have evolved significantly over the past decade, with improved crediting strategies, higher participation rates, and more consumer-friendly structures. If you are considering moving from a traditional fixed annuity into an indexed strategy, understanding how fixed indexed annuities work can clarify whether that transition supports your goals. Conversely, some retirees move from indexed products back into fixed annuities when they prefer simplicity and declared rates. Comparing fixed vs. indexed annuities side by side helps determine which structure aligns with your risk tolerance and income timeline.
Many retirees pursue 1035 exchanges specifically to enhance lifetime income. If your original annuity lacks a strong income rider — or if the payout factors are no longer competitive — you may significantly improve future cash flow by repositioning funds. Understanding how annuities provide lifetime income is central to this evaluation. Some newer contracts offer higher payout percentages at specific ages or stronger roll-up provisions during the deferral phase. Even small differences in payout factors can create meaningful increases in lifetime income when applied over decades of retirement. For contracts where GLWB mechanics are the primary driver of an exchange decision, our resource on how GLWBs work covers how roll-up rates, payout percentages, and income base calculations vary across products and how to evaluate whether the new contract’s income mechanics genuinely improve on the existing contract’s structure. If an income rider is what you need but do not currently have, our guide on what an income rider is explains the structure from the ground up before any exchange decision is made.
When a 1035 Exchange Does NOT Make Sense
Not every exchange makes financial sense, and the discipline to decline an exchange that does not pencil out is as important as the skill to identify one that does. The most common reason to decline a 1035 exchange is the surrender charge math: if the existing contract has a meaningful surrender charge remaining — particularly if it is in the first third of a surrender period — the improvement in the new contract may not overcome the charge within a reasonable period. The analysis must compare the cost of exiting against the long-term benefit of improved terms. If the existing contract will have surrendered fully in 18 to 24 months and the new contract does not offer a compelling immediate benefit, waiting for surrender-free access and then making the exchange typically produces better outcomes.
A second reason to decline is the loss of valuable existing riders or features. Some older annuity contracts contain features that are no longer available in the current marketplace — specific death benefit structures, grandfathered crediting rate minimums, or income riders from periods when payout percentages were more generous. Before exchanging, confirm whether the features being lost can be replicated or exceeded in the new contract. Our resource on the annuity rescue plan covers how to evaluate whether an existing contract should be restructured, exchanged, or maintained based on a complete feature-by-feature analysis. Reviewing annuity free withdrawal rules within your existing contract may also reveal liquidity options that reduce urgency — if the existing contract’s 10% annual free withdrawal provision already provides access to the funds you need, the immediate pressure to exchange may be less than initially assumed. Getting a second opinion on your annuity quote ensures the proposed replacement genuinely improves your position rather than simply creating a new surrender period and commission event with no net benefit to you.
Tax Mechanics — How Cost Basis and Gains Transfer
Tax considerations remain central throughout this process. A properly executed 1035 exchange must be completed directly between insurance carriers to preserve tax deferral — funds cannot pass through your personal bank account at any point. If structured correctly, the cost basis transfers intact to the new contract and gains remain untaxed until withdrawal. This makes 1035 exchanges especially powerful for individuals holding significant unrealized gains inside older contracts. Instead of triggering immediate taxation on those gains — which would be taxable as ordinary income, not capital gains — you retain compounding benefits within a potentially stronger annuity structure.
For non-qualified annuities (funded with after-tax dollars), the cost basis that transfers determines the exclusion ratio for future income distributions. The exclusion ratio determines what percentage of each annuitized payment is treated as return of principal (tax-free) versus gain (taxable as ordinary income). Preserving the cost basis through a 1035 exchange preserves this exclusion ratio advantage. For qualified annuities — those held inside an IRA or funded with pre-tax 401(k) rollover funds — all distributions are taxable as ordinary income regardless of the exchange mechanics, because the tax deferral and basis tracking are controlled by the qualified account rules rather than the annuity contract itself. Understanding how annuities are taxed across qualified and non-qualified structures ensures the exchange decision accounts for the correct tax framework before proceeding.
Partial 1035 Exchanges — Splitting an Existing Contract
A partial 1035 exchange transfers a portion of an existing annuity’s value into a new contract while leaving the remainder in the original contract. The IRS permits partial exchanges, subject to specific rules designed to prevent abuse — particularly the use of partial exchanges to accelerate access to tax-deferred gains in disguised taxable transactions. Under IRS guidelines, a partial 1035 exchange followed by a surrender or distribution from either contract within a certain period may cause the IRS to re-characterize the exchange as a taxable distribution rather than a qualified 1035 exchange. The practical implication: partial exchanges that are followed by distributions from either contract within 180 days risk losing the tax-deferred exchange treatment and triggering taxable gain recognition. Buyers considering partial exchanges should confirm the exchange and any subsequent distribution plan with a qualified tax professional before proceeding to ensure the timeline and structure satisfy IRS requirements. Partial exchanges are most commonly used in two scenarios: laddering — where a portion of one contract is exchanged into a new contract with a different term or product type while the balance remains in the original — and income strategy separation, where a portion is exchanged into an income-focused contract while the remainder stays in an accumulation vehicle. Our resource on laddering annuities covers how staggered maturities and product combinations can be structured to create rolling liquidity and diversified growth approaches, and partial 1035 exchanges are a tool that can facilitate that structure efficiently.
How to Execute a 1035 Exchange — The Process Step by Step
The 1035 exchange process is more involved than a standard annuity purchase but is straightforward when managed correctly with the right broker support. The process begins with a comprehensive analysis of the existing contract: surrender value, surrender charge schedule, cost basis, accumulated gain, existing rider benefits, and projected future performance under current credited rate assumptions. This analysis defines the starting point and establishes what must be exceeded by the new contract for the exchange to be financially justified. The second step is identifying and comparing new contract options — evaluating credited rates, income rider structures, surrender period terms, carrier financial strength, and any bonus provisions against the specific needs identified in the analysis of the existing contract.
Once the new contract is selected, the exchange is initiated by completing the new carrier’s application along with a 1035 exchange form that directs the existing carrier to transfer the funds directly to the new carrier. The existing carrier will process the surrender of the old contract and issue a check payable to the new carrier — never to the policyholder directly. Processing time typically ranges from 30 to 60 days depending on the carriers involved and the complexity of the contracts. During this period, neither the existing contract nor the new contract is earning credited interest or rider benefits on the full exchange amount. Timing the exchange to minimize this neutral period — for example, by initiating shortly after the existing contract’s crediting date — can reduce lost interest. For buyers using the exchange to fund a transfer from an IRA or 401(k) into a new annuity, our guides on IRA to annuity transfers and 401(k) to annuity rollovers cover the specific mechanics and tax preservation rules for qualified account transitions, which follow different rules than the Section 1035 exchange framework used for non-qualified annuity-to-annuity transfers.
Ultimately, a 1035 exchange is not about replacing a contract for the sake of change — it is about measurable improvement. That may mean higher guaranteed rates, stronger lifetime income, reduced internal costs, better index crediting potential, improved beneficiary provisions, or simplified portfolio structure. It requires careful side-by-side comparison and objective analysis. Reviewing annuity beneficiary death benefits as part of that analysis ensures the new contract’s death benefit provisions — enhanced death benefit, return of premium, spousal continuation rights — are at least as strong as the existing contract’s before the exchange is finalized. At Diversified Insurance Brokers, we guide clients through 1035 exchanges by thoroughly reviewing both the old and new annuity contracts — ensuring you improve your position rather than simply starting over with a new surrender period.
Ready to evaluate whether a 1035 exchange makes sense for your current annuity?
Request Your 1035 Exchange Review
Financial Protection Essentials
Understand annuity guarantees, interest rate examples by investment size, and how retirement income strategies work in practice.
Talk With an Advisor Today
Choose how you’d like to connect—call or message us, then book a time that works for you.
Schedule here:
calendly.com/jason-dibcompanies/diversified-quotes
Licensed in all 50 states • Fiduciary, family-owned since 1980
Can I do a 1035 exchange if my annuity still has surrender charges?
Yes — a 1035 exchange can be executed even if your existing annuity has remaining surrender charges. The exchange does not waive or eliminate those charges. When you initiate a 1035 exchange, the existing carrier processes a surrender of your contract, which triggers any applicable surrender charge on the amount being transferred. The net surrender value — after deducting the surrender charge — is then transferred directly to the new carrier. The IRS 1035 rules apply to the tax treatment of the exchange, not to the surrender charge provisions of the contract. Whether a 1035 exchange makes financial sense when surrender charges remain requires a break-even analysis: how long will it take for the improvement in the new contract to exceed the surrender charge cost? If the new contract offers meaningfully better rates, income features, or a significant premium bonus, the break-even may be short enough to justify the exchange even with remaining charges. If the existing contract is within 12 to 18 months of surrender-free status, waiting often produces a better net outcome. The analysis is specific to your contract’s current surrender charge, the accumulated value, and the measurable benefit difference in the new contract.
Can I do a 1035 exchange from an annuity into a life insurance policy?
No — this exchange direction is not permitted under IRS Section 1035. The tax code allows life insurance to be exchanged into annuities, and life insurance to be exchanged into other life insurance, and annuities to be exchanged into other annuities. However, an exchange from an annuity into a life insurance policy is specifically not allowed under 1035. If you want to use accumulated annuity funds to purchase a life insurance policy, you would need to surrender the annuity — recognizing the taxable gain — and then use the after-tax proceeds to fund the life insurance premium. Alternatively, there are planning strategies involving annuity income distributions used to fund premium payments on life insurance that can be structured to achieve a similar economic outcome over time, but these do not qualify as 1035 exchanges and should be coordinated with a tax advisor. The practical takeaway: if your goal is repositioning annuity value into life insurance coverage, the 1035 framework does not apply and the tax cost of accessing those funds must be factored into the decision.
What happens to my cost basis in a 1035 exchange?
Your cost basis transfers intact from the old contract to the new contract in a properly executed 1035 exchange. Cost basis is the amount you have invested in the annuity with after-tax dollars — the premiums paid that were not previously tax-deductible. In a non-qualified annuity, the cost basis determines the exclusion ratio for future income distributions: the portion of each distribution that represents return of principal (tax-free) versus gain (taxable as ordinary income). By transferring the cost basis intact through the exchange, you preserve the same exclusion ratio advantage in the new contract that existed in the old contract. The accumulated gain — the difference between the current contract value and the cost basis — also transfers without recognition. You will eventually pay ordinary income tax on those gains when distributed, but the 1035 exchange defers that recognition for as long as the funds remain in the new annuity structure. This basis preservation is one of the most financially significant features of a properly executed 1035 exchange for policyholders with large unrealized gains relative to their original premium.
Can I exchange from a variable annuity into a fixed or indexed annuity?
Yes — a 1035 exchange from a variable annuity into a fixed annuity or fixed indexed annuity is a permitted and common exchange direction. Variable annuity holders who want to eliminate market risk while preserving tax deferral frequently use 1035 exchanges to reposition into fixed or indexed contracts. The exchange follows the same carrier-to-carrier transfer process as any other 1035 exchange, and the same rules regarding surrender charges, cost basis transfer, and qualified vs. non-qualified tax treatment apply. One important consideration specific to variable annuities: some older variable annuity contracts contain legacy guaranteed minimum death benefits (GMDBs), guaranteed minimum income benefits (GMIBs), or other living benefit riders that have significant present value — particularly for variable annuity contracts purchased before 2008 that may have been issued with guaranteed minimum returns during the market turmoil period. Surrendering a variable annuity through a 1035 exchange permanently terminates these legacy guarantees, which may not be available in the current marketplace. Before exchanging out of a variable annuity with legacy benefit riders, a comprehensive analysis of the current value of those riders — and whether equivalent or superior features can be obtained in the new contract — is essential due diligence.
How do I know if my existing annuity is actually underperforming or just appears that way?
This is one of the most important questions in any exchange analysis, because annuity illustrations — both for the existing contract and proposed replacements — can be structured to make almost any exchange appear favorable on paper. The honest answer requires comparing identical scenarios across both contracts with identical assumptions, not cherry-picked projections. Evaluating your existing contract accurately requires: (1) confirming the current declared rate or crediting parameters — not the original illustrated rate, but what the contract is actually crediting today; (2) identifying what the contract will credit at renewal if its current guarantee period is ending; (3) reviewing the surrender charge schedule to understand when full liquidity is available; (4) identifying any riders or features in the existing contract and their current and future value; and (5) projecting the existing contract’s accumulation value and any income base under realistic assumptions for the remaining deferral period. Comparing that honest projection against the new contract’s projection under the same realistic assumptions — not against the new contract’s best-case illustrated scenario — determines whether the exchange produces genuine improvement. Our resource on getting a second opinion on your annuity quote covers how to evaluate whether a proposed exchange is genuinely in your interest rather than in the interest of a commission transaction.
About the Author:
Jason Stolz, CLTC, CRPC, DIA, CAA and Chief Underwriter at Diversified Insurance Brokers (NPN 20471358), is a senior insurance and retirement professional with more than 25 years of real-world experience helping individuals, families, and business owners protect their income, assets, and long-term financial stability. As a long-time partner of the nationally licensed independent agency Diversified Insurance Brokers, Jason provides trusted guidance across multiple specialties—including fixed and indexed annuities, long-term care planning, personal and business disability insurance, life insurance solutions, Group Health, Travel Medical and Evacuation Insurance, and short-term health coverage. Diversified Insurance Brokers maintains active contracts with over 100 highly rated insurance carriers, ensuring clients have access to a broad and competitive marketplace.
His practical, education-first approach has earned recognition in publications such as VoyageATL, and contributions from his agency featured in Kiplinger and GoBankingRates— highlighting his commitment to financial clarity and client-focused planning. Drawing on deep product knowledge and years of hands-on field experience, Jason helps clients evaluate carriers, compare strategies, and build retirement and protection plans that are both secure and cost-efficient. Visitors who want to explore current annuity rates and compare options across multiple insurers can also use this annuity quote and comparison tool.
Browse More Resources: Return to our complete Fixed Indexed Annuity Products & Education guide — covering FIA products and education from top carriers.
Last Reviewed: June 25, 2026 |
Reviewed by: Jason Stolz, CLTC, CRPC, DIA, CAA
Chief Underwriter, Diversified Insurance Brokers, Inc. | NPN: 20471358 | Diversified Insurance Brokers, Inc. — Licensed in all 50 states
Fact Checked by: Tonia Pettitt, CMIP©
Medicare Specialist, Diversified Insurance Brokers, Inc. | NPN: 14374308 | Diversified Insurance Brokers, Inc. — Licensed in all 50 states
Did you find this content helpful? Leave us a Google review — it helps others find trustworthy guidance too.
Editorial Standards: Diversified Insurance Brokers maintains rigorous editorial standards to ensure accuracy, clarity, and independence in all content. Learn more about our editorial standards and commitment to transparency.
